What is the best Seafood restaurant in The Castro?

Saru Sushi Bar is our top pick for Seafood restaurants in The Castro, scoring 8.8/10. MICHELIN-recognized neighborhood sushi bar with meticulous fish and tight rolls.

Any insider tips for Saru Sushi Bar?

Go right at open for bar seats and fastest service.

What should I order at Saru Sushi Bar?

Spicy scallop roll, negihama roll, chef’s special roll

When should I visit Saru Sushi Bar?

Arrive early evening to avoid the line

Who should go to Saru Sushi Bar?

Roll lovers who value immaculate fish

Any insider tips for Anchor Oyster Bar?

Seats are limited—solo diners score bar spots fastest.

What should I order at Anchor Oyster Bar?

Half-dozen oysters, clam chowder, cioppino

When should I visit Anchor Oyster Bar?

Early evening before peak wait times

Who should go to Anchor Oyster Bar?

Seafood lovers and neighborhood regulars

Any insider tips for Fisch & Flore?

Bar seats are best for quick oysters and a drink pre-plans.

What should I order at Fisch & Flore?

Grilled oysters; fish and chips; calamari

When should I visit Fisch & Flore?

Happy hour or weekend brunch for energy and value

Who should go to Fisch & Flore?

Oyster slurpers and cocktail-hour crews

Any insider tips for Billingsgate?

Check the case for limited-run catches used in daily specials.

What should I order at Billingsgate?

Lobster roll; chowder cup; poke bowl

When should I visit Billingsgate?

Midday for the fastest counter service

Who should go to Billingsgate?

Quality-first seafood fans on a schedule

Best Seafood Restaurants in The Castro (94114)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Saru Sushi Bar

MICHELIN-recognized neighborhood sushi bar with meticulous fish and tight rolls.

Notable Picks

#1 Saru Sushi Bar

8.8

$$$$ Noe Valley

Vibes: Date Night Magic Trendy Table Hotspots Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Tiny Noe Valley favorite (since 2012) known for pristine fish and well-executed classic and contemporary rolls alongside strong nigiri. Lines move fast, and the focus stays on clean flavors over heavy sauces.

Must-Try Dishes: Spicy scallop roll, Negihama (yellowtail-scallion) roll, Rainbow roll

What makes it special: MICHELIN-recognized neighborhood sushi bar with meticulous fish and tight rolls.

View Full Review →

#2 Anchor Oyster Bar

8.6

$$ The Castro

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Hidden Gems Heaven Date Night Magic

Tiny Castro institution (since 1977) serving spot-on seafood—oysters, chowder, cioppino—in a classic counter setting. Locals line up for simple, impeccably fresh plates and old-school hospitality.

Must-Try Dishes: Oysters on the Half Shell, New England Clam Chowder, Cioppino

What makes it special: Castro legacy counter famed for pristine shellfish and cioppino.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Fisch & Flore

7.9

$$ The Castro

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Happy Hour Hotspots Girls Night Out Approved Trendy Table Hotspots

Seafood-forward Castro hangout with cocktails, happy hour, and a brunch-to-dinner menu. Expect oysters, fried-to-order fish, and playful Mediterranean-leaning plates in a social room right on Market.

Must-Try Dishes: Fisch and Chips, Grilled Oysters, Calamari

What makes it special: Seafood plates, cocktails, and weekend brunch on a lively Castro corner.

View Full Review →

#4 Billingsgate

7.8

$$ Noe Valley

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Business Lunch Power Players Healthy Haven Hidden Gems Heaven

Noe Valley seafood market-café from the Four Star Seafood team offering rolls, chowder, and market-fresh plates alongside retail fish. It’s the neighborhood’s grab-and-go answer for high-quality seafood at fair prices.

Must-Try Dishes: Lobster Roll, Clam Chowder, Tuna Poke Bowl

What makes it special: Market-fresh seafood prepared simply, backed by a respected Bay Area wholesaler.

View Full Review →