What is the best Seafood restaurant in Wicker Park & West Town?

Alegrias Seafood is our top pick for Seafood restaurants in Wicker Park & West Town, scoring 8.6/10. High-volume Nayarit-style seafood platters in a loud, festive room.

Any insider tips for Alegrias Seafood?

Take advantage of the BYO policy and arrive early to secure a patio table.

What should I order at Alegrias Seafood?

Chapuzon Del Mar, whole fried red snapper, langostinos Nayarit-style.

When should I visit Alegrias Seafood?

Weekend dinners when the room is packed and buzzing.

Who should go to Alegrias Seafood?

Groups and families craving big-format Mexican seafood feasts.

Any insider tips for Mariscos La Costa?

Come with a small group and split a whole fried fish plus a couple of seafood appetizers instead of ordering solo plates.

What should I order at Mariscos La Costa?

Shrimp empanadas, whole fried fish, ceviche tostada.

When should I visit Mariscos La Costa?

Weekend evenings or late dinners when the room is buzzing.

Who should go to Mariscos La Costa?

Seafood lovers planning a casual, shareable Mexican dinner.

Any insider tips for El Barco Mariscos?

Share a whole snapper and a parrillada instead of over-ordering individual plates.

What should I order at El Barco Mariscos?

Whole fried red snapper, seafood parrillada, shrimp cocktail.

When should I visit El Barco Mariscos?

Prime weekend evenings for full patio and party energy.

Who should go to El Barco Mariscos?

Groups planning casual, lively seafood dinners with drinks.

Any insider tips for The Boil Cajun Seafood?

Order sauce on the heavier side and mix in corn and potatoes to stretch the boil.

When should I visit The Boil Cajun Seafood?

Evenings and weekends when groups pack the dining room.

Who should go to The Boil Cajun Seafood?

Friends who don’t mind getting messy over shared seafood.

Best Seafood Restaurants in Wicker Park & West Town (60622)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Alegrias Seafood

High-volume Nayarit-style seafood platters in a loud, festive room.

Notable Picks

#1 Alegrias Seafood

8.6

$ Ukrainian Village

Vibes: Group Dining Gatherings Family Friendly Favorites Hidden Gems Heaven Outdoor Dining Oasis

Alegrias Seafood is a Nayarit-style mariscos house where platters of langostinos, whole fried snapper, and ceviches land on big tables in a loud, BYO-friendly room. Locals use it for celebratory seafood feasts when they want serious shellfish, big portions, and a rowdy West Town atmosphere without heading downtown.

Must-Try Dishes: Chapuzon Del Mar mixed seafood platter, Whole fried red snapper (huachinango), Langostinos Estilo Nayarit

What makes it special: High-volume Nayarit-style seafood platters in a loud, festive room.

View Full Review →

#2 Mariscos La Costa

8.2

$$ West Town

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Happy Hour Hotspots Trendy Table Hotspots

Mariscos La Costa is a family-run Mexican seafood spot where shrimp empanadas, ceviche mixto, and whole fried fish anchor a menu built for sharing. It’s the slightly lower-key mariscos option on Ashland, with friendly service, fair pricing, and a loyal local crowd that treats it as a neighborhood standby.

Must-Try Dishes: Shrimp Empanadas, Whole Fried Fish with Shrimp, Mixed Ceviche Tostada

What makes it special: Seafood-forward Mexican plates and micheladas built for sharing and celebrations.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 El Barco Mariscos

7.9

$$ Wicker Park

Vibes: Birthday & Celebration Central Group Dining Gatherings Outdoor Dining Oasis Trendy Table Hotspots

El Barco Mariscos is a long-running Mexican seafood institution known for its whole fried red snapper, towering seafood cocktails, and frozen margaritas. The space is big, boisterous, and built for groups, making it a go-to for casual celebrations and patio dinners when diners want quantity and energy as much as finesse.

Must-Try Dishes: Whole fried red snapper, Seafood parrillada platter, Coctel de camarón shrimp cocktail

What makes it special: Decades-old Mexican mariscos spot famous for whole red snapper and big platters.

View Full Review →

#4 The Boil Cajun Seafood

7.7

$$$$ East Ukrainian Village

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Hidden Gems Heaven

The Boil Cajun Seafood brings a Gulf-style boil format to East Ukrainian Village, with bags of crab, shrimp, and clams tossed in garlicky Cajun butter. It’s a bibs-on, hands-in dinner built around sharing, where tables fill with plastic-lined trays, shell piles, and plenty of seasoning.

Must-Try Dishes: Build-your-own seafood boil with crab and shrimp, Char-grilled oysters, Garlic butter Cajun noodles

What makes it special: Cajun-style seafood boils with customizable spice and sauce levels.

View Full Review →