What is the best Spanish restaurant in Midtown East?

Alcala Restaurant is our top pick for Spanish restaurants in Midtown East, scoring 8.3/10. Multi-generational family ownership with the Martinez brothers creating an authentic Spanish atmosphere rarely found in Midtown

Any insider tips for Alcala Restaurant?

Ask for outdoor igloo seating in winter with Bluetooth speakers for your own playlist

What should I order at Alcala Restaurant?

Chipirones (squid in ink), Paella Valenciana, house wine

When should I visit Alcala Restaurant?

Weekday lunch for quiet elegance, Friday dinner for energy

Who should go to Alcala Restaurant?

UN diplomats, Spanish cuisine purists, romantic couples

Best Spanish Restaurants in Midtown East (10017)

1 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Alcala Restaurant

Multi-generational family ownership with the Martinez brothers creating an authentic Spanish atmosphere rarely found in Midtown

Notable Picks

#1 Alcala Restaurant

8.3

$$$ Turtle Bay

Vibes: Hidden Gems Heaven Date Night Magic Business Lunch Power Players Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Family-run Basque restaurant operating since 2003, two blocks from Grand Central and the United Nations. Chef-owner Jesús Martínez brings Northern Spanish traditions to life through expertly executed seafood-forward dishes and an all-Spanish wine list that has earned loyal regulars including diplomats and heads of state.

Must-Try Dishes: Paella de Mariscos, Chipirones en Su Tinta, Gambas al Ajillo

What makes it special: Multi-generational family ownership with the Martinez brothers creating an authentic Spanish atmosphere rarely found in Midtown

View Full Review →