What is the best Spanish restaurant in Park Slope?

Surfish Bistro is our top pick for Spanish restaurants in Park Slope, scoring 8.5/10. A chef-led Peruvian bistro where ceviche, chaufa, and composed seafood plates bring a more refined Latin experience to 3rd Avenue.

Any insider tips for Surfish Bistro?

Build your meal around one ceviche to share, then split a couple of hot entrées—the kitchen cooks seafood best when the table isn’t over-ordering.

What should I order at Surfish Bistro?

Ceviche Mixto, Arroz Chaufa, Lomo Saltado with fries and rice.

When should I visit Surfish Bistro?

Prime-time weekends require reservations; late weeknights are calmer.

Who should go to Surfish Bistro?

Ceviche lovers and date-night diners seeking polished Latin plates.

Any insider tips for Mercado Central NYC – Copa y Caña?

Buy a favorite tin or jamón at the shop and have the café plate it for a small fee to turn shopping into an impromptu tapas session.

What should I order at Mercado Central NYC – Copa y Caña?

Tortilla española, a tinned-fish plate with boquerones, squid-ink rice special if offered.

When should I visit Mercado Central NYC – Copa y Caña?

Late afternoons and early evenings before peak weekend crowds.

Who should go to Mercado Central NYC – Copa y Caña?

Spanish product nerds and tapas fans who appreciate tinned fish.

Any insider tips for Colombia in Park Slope?

Start with guacamole and plantain chips, then plan on splitting one or two mains—portions run large.

What should I order at Colombia in Park Slope?

Bandeja Paisa, Ajiaco soup, Entraña Asada with rice and beans.

When should I visit Colombia in Park Slope?

Weeknights before 7pm or weekend lunches to avoid waits.

Who should go to Colombia in Park Slope?

Dinosaurs who love huge platters, rice, beans and grilled meats.

Any insider tips for El Viejo Yayo 2?

Lunch and early-bird combo plates deliver the biggest value for the portion sizes.

What should I order at El Viejo Yayo 2?

Seafood Paella, Ropa Vieja, Mofongo de Pernil with garlicky broth.

When should I visit El Viejo Yayo 2?

Early evening or weekend lunchtime before the dining room fills.

Who should go to El Viejo Yayo 2?

Groups and families craving hearty Spanish-Latin comfort food.

Any insider tips for Elora's Restaurant?

Check out weekday lunch specials—many Spanish plates are significantly cheaper midday.

When should I visit Elora's Restaurant?

Weekday lunches or early dinners for the calmest dining room.

Who should go to Elora's Restaurant?

Families and groups wanting relaxed paella and fajitas nearby.

Best Spanish Restaurants in Park Slope (11215)

5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Surfish Bistro

A chef-led Peruvian bistro where ceviche, chaufa, and composed seafood plates bring a more refined Latin experience to 3rd Avenue.

Notable Picks

#1 Surfish Bistro

8.5

$$$$ Gowanus

Vibes: Date Night Magic Trendy Table Hotspots Girls Night Out Approved Business Lunch Power Players

Chef Miguel Aguilar’s Peruvian bistro leans seafood-heavy, with ceviches, lomo saltado, and chaufa that appeal to diners craving bright, Spanish-speaking Latin flavors in a more polished setting. It’s the most chef-driven option in the area for paella-adjacent rice dishes and ceviche-focused meals.

Must-Try Dishes: Ceviche Mixto, Arroz Chaufa, Lomo Saltado

What makes it special: A chef-led Peruvian bistro where ceviche, chaufa, and composed seafood plates bring a more refined Latin experience to 3rd Avenue.

View Full Review →

#2 Mercado Central NYC – Copa y Caña

8.2

$ Gowanus

Vibes: Hidden Gems Heaven Girls Night Out Approved Solo Dining Sanctuaries Quick Bites Champions

Spanish colmado and tapas bar in Gowanus combining shelves of tinned fish, jamón, and pantry staples with a small café in back. Guests snack on boquerones, tortilla española, and squid-ink rice with vermouth or wine, making it feel closest to an in-Spain pintxo bar experience in the neighborhood.

Must-Try Dishes: Tortilla Española, Boquerones with Olive Oil, Squid-Ink Rice with Piquillo Peppers

What makes it special: A Spanish specialty market certified as an official colmado where you can both shop for imports and sit down to serious tapas.

View Full Review →

#3 Colombia in Park Slope

8.1

$$ Park Slope

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Girls Night Out Approved

A busy Fifth Avenue fixture for Colombian home cooking, pouring sangria and cocktails alongside bandeja paisa, ajiaco, and grilled steaks. Portions are generous, prices stay moderate, and regulars treat it as their neighborhood Latin dining room.

Must-Try Dishes: Bandeja Paisa, Ajiaco Soup, Entraña Asada (Skirt Steak)

What makes it special: Colombian classics like bandeja paisa and ajiaco served in a casual, lively room with strong value and cocktails.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#4 El Viejo Yayo 2

7.6

$ South Slope

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Quick Bites Champions

Long-running Park Slope standby for big plates of Spanish and Latin comfort food, from seafood paella to ropa vieja and mofongo. Locals lean on it for hearty, shareable platters, generous portions, and all-day hours more than precise plating.

Must-Try Dishes: Seafood Paella, Ropa Vieja, Mofongo de Pernil

What makes it special: A sprawling Spanish-Latin menu with paellas, mofongos, and daily specials served from breakfast through late night.

View Full Review →

#5 Elora's Restaurant

7.6

$$ Windsor Terrace

Vibes: Family Friendly Favorites Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance

Cozy Windsor Terrace spot blending Mexican and Spanish cooking, where fajitas and tacos share the menu with pan-Spanish paellas. It’s more about relaxed, affordable plates and neighborhood familiarity than polished service or design.

Must-Try Dishes: Elora's Seafood Linguine Paella, La Placita Fajitas, Churrasco with Chimichurri

What makes it special: A neighborhood Mexican-Spanish hybrid where sizzling fajitas and multi-seafood paellas come with friendly prices and unfussy service.

View Full Review →