What is the best Spanish restaurant in Williamsburg?

MyMoon is our top pick for Spanish restaurants in Williamsburg, scoring 8.8/10. Spanish and Catalan cooking served in a striking indoor-outdoor factory conversion.

Any insider tips for MyMoon?

If you like the space, check their event calendar and availability for future celebrations.

When should I visit MyMoon?

Evenings for the full lighting, courtyard, and event energy.

Who should go to MyMoon?

Couples and groups planning stylish dinners or celebrations.

Any insider tips for Bahia Restaurant and Cafe?

Pair pupusas with a seafood stew and share across the table to sample more of the menu.

What should I order at Bahia Restaurant and Cafe?

Pupusas revueltas, crema de mariscos, casamiento with grilled steak.

When should I visit Bahia Restaurant and Cafe?

Lunch or early dinner for relaxed service and easier seating.

Who should go to Bahia Restaurant and Cafe?

Families and groups craving hearty Latin and Spanish-influenced plates.

Any insider tips for Emperador Elias Restaurant?

Check for karaoke or live-entertainment nights if you want extra energy with dinner.

What should I order at Emperador Elias Restaurant?

Mofongo with shrimp, churrasco steak, seafood rice.

When should I visit Emperador Elias Restaurant?

Evenings and late nights when the bar, TVs, and music are active.

Who should go to Emperador Elias Restaurant?

Groups wanting big portions, drinks, and a casual game-night spot.

Best Spanish Restaurants in Williamsburg (11211)

Q: What should I order at MyMoon?

Seafood paella, croquetas de jamón, patatas bravas.

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

MyMoon

Spanish and Catalan cooking served in a striking indoor-outdoor factory conversion.

Notable Picks

#1 MyMoon

8.8

$$$ Williamsburg - Northside

Vibes: Date Night Magic Trendy Table Hotspots Group Dining Gatherings Outdoor Dining Oasis

MyMoon is a dramatic Spanish restaurant and event space in a converted factory, known for Catalan-leaning tapas, paella, and a lush courtyard that fits special-occasion dinners as comfortably as weddings. High-volume reviews across platforms highlight polished service, strong execution on classics, and an atmosphere that feels built for date nights and celebrations.

Must-Try Dishes: Seafood paella, Croquetas de jamón, Patatas bravas

What makes it special: Spanish and Catalan cooking served in a striking indoor-outdoor factory conversion.

View Full Review →

#2 Bahia Restaurant and Cafe

8.3

$$ East Williamsburg

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Group Dining Gatherings

Bahia Restaurant and Cafe leans Salvadoran and broader Latin while still nodding to Spanish coastal flavors, with pupusas, hearty seafood stews, and generous plates that draw neighborhood regulars. It’s casual and welcoming, with portions and pricing that make it a strong value play for families and small groups.

Must-Try Dishes: Pupusas revueltas, Casamiento with grilled steak, Crema de mariscos

What makes it special: A neighborhood standby for pupusas, seafood plates, and Latin-Spanish comfort food.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Emperador Elias Restaurant

7.8

$$$ Williamsburg - Southside

Vibes: Group Dining Gatherings Sports Bar Central Late Night Legends Hidden Gems Heaven

Emperador Elias blends Caribbean and Spanish influences in a lively bar-restaurant setting with TVs, music, and late hours. Mofongo, grilled meats, and seafood plates make it a useful option when you want big flavors, drinks, and a social room more than a quiet sit-down meal.

Must-Try Dishes: Mofongo with garlicky shrimp, Churrasco steak, Seafood rice (arroz con mariscos)

What makes it special: Caribbean-Spanish plates served in a bar-forward room with TVs and music.

View Full Review →