What is the best Wings restaurant in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn?

Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn is our top pick for Wings restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn, scoring 8.8/10. Buffalo-native owners serving crisp, saucy wings in a central food hall.

Any insider tips for Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Order a larger platter to share; wings stay crisp for a while.

What should I order at Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Medium Buffalo wings, lemon pepper dozen, fries on the side.

When should I visit Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Lunch or early evening before peak market crowds.

Who should go to Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn?

Wing purists who want classic Buffalo done right.

Any insider tips for Superfine?

Sit near the bar for the best view of the open space and art.

What should I order at Superfine?

Jerk spiced wings, seasonal salad, a rotating entree special.

When should I visit Superfine?

Evenings for full kitchen, music, and lively energy.

Who should go to Superfine?

Groups and couples wanting wings plus cocktails and mains.

Any insider tips for Henry Street Ale House?

Check rotating tap lists; certain beers pair especially well with wings.

What should I order at Henry Street Ale House?

Buffalo wings, a house burger, and a rotating draft beer.

When should I visit Henry Street Ale House?

Happy hour or game nights for peak pub atmosphere.

Who should go to Henry Street Ale House?

Pub fans who want pints, sports, and solid wings.

Any insider tips for DoubleUp Eats?

Order larger combo sets if you’re feeding a group or planning leftovers.

When should I visit DoubleUp Eats?

Evenings and weekends for the broadest comfort-meal selection.

Who should go to DoubleUp Eats?

Budget-minded diners craving crispy Korean fried chicken delivery.

Best Wings Restaurants in Brooklyn Heights & Downtown Brooklyn (11201)

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn

Buffalo-native owners serving crisp, saucy wings in a central food hall.

Notable Picks

#1 Dan and John's Wings - Brooklyn

8.8

$ Downtown Brooklyn

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics Food Hall Frenzy Group Dining Gatherings

Dan and John's Wings operates inside DeKalb Market Hall, turning out classic Buffalo-style wings from two Buffalo natives who focus almost entirely on the bird. Locals and office workers treat it as the go-to for saucy, crispy wings that hold up for takeout and game-day orders.

Must-Try Dishes: Medium Buffalo wings, Lemon pepper wings, Garlic parmesan wings

What makes it special: Buffalo-native owners serving crisp, saucy wings in a central food hall.

View Full Review →

#2 Superfine

8.4

$$$ DUMBO

Vibes: Trendy Table Hotspots Group Dining Gatherings Instagram Worthy Wonders Date Night Magic

Superfine in DUMBO is a loft-like, art-filled restaurant where jerk spiced chicken wings share the menu with market-driven small plates and mains. People come as much for cocktails, live-feeling energy, and the design-forward room as for the food, making the wings a standout starter in a more polished setting.

Must-Try Dishes: Jerk spiced chicken wings, Butternut squash soup, Pan fried gnocchi cacio e pepe

What makes it special: Design-forward DUMBO restaurant where jerk wings headline the bar menu.

View Full Review →

#3 Henry Street Ale House

8.0

$ Brooklyn Heights

Vibes: Sports Bar Central Comfort Food Classics Group Dining Gatherings Happy Hour Hotspots

Henry Street Ale House in Brooklyn Heights is a long-running neighborhood pub known for its rotating taps and classic bar food, including a well-loved plate of wings. Regulars settle in for pints, burgers, and wings in a wood-paneled room that feels built for lingering over a game or casual catch-up.

Must-Try Dishes: Buffalo wings, Chicken tenders, Burger with fries

What makes it special: Classic Brooklyn Heights ale house where wings pair with serious beer.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#4 DoubleUp Eats

7.8

$$$ Downtown Brooklyn

Vibes: Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Comfort Food Classics Hidden Gems Heaven

DoubleUp Eats runs a ghost kitchen at 397–399 Bridge Street that leans into Nashville hot chicken and Korean-style fried chicken, with wings and sandwiches built for delivery. It’s a newer option downtown for crisp, heavily sauced wings that arrive hot to nearby apartments and offices.

Must-Try Dishes: Triple-Fried Korean Fried Chicken, Soy-Braised Beef, Crispy Wings

What makes it special: Family-run Korean fried chicken and comfort plates cooked fresh to order.

View Full Review →