Best Date Night Magic Sushi Restaurants in Old Town
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
SHŌ
Music-driven omakase that blends serious technique with interactive, DIY hand rolls.
Notable Picks
#1
SHŌ
8.6
SHŌ is a modern Old Town omakase where chef Mari Katsumura runs a tightly edited 10-course menu that moves from sashimi to playful composed dishes and DIY hand rolls. The counter-only format, music-forward room, and focus on seasonal Japanese technique with global twists make it one of the most ambitious sushi experiences in 60610.
Must-Try Dishes:
Corn cream croquette with jalapeño and yuzu, Sukiyaki-inspired wagyu hand roll, Tonkotsu ramen with Iberico ham
What makes it special: Music-driven omakase that blends serious technique with interactive, DIY hand rolls.
8.3
Chicago’s original sushi bar, Kamehachi has anchored Old Town since 1967 with a sprawling menu of maki, nigiri, hot appetizers, and combo platters. It’s less about avant-garde omakase and more about reliable rolls, bento-style meals, and a neighborhood crowd that spans families, regulars, and pre-Second City dinners.
Must-Try Dishes:
Crouching Tuna Hidden Crab roll, Spicy Tuna Deluxe roll, Kamehachi Combo
What makes it special: Long-running Old Town institution where generations of Chicagoans had their first sushi.
Worthy Picks
7.7
Hom Mali Thai Sushi is a newer Old Town spot pairing classic Thai curries and noodles with a compact sushi menu in a polished, relaxed dining room. Locals use it as a weeknight standby when a table of pad thai, curry, and a few maki rolls sounds better than committing to a full omakase.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pad Thai, Green curry with vegetables, Spicy tuna roll
What makes it special: Thai dishes and approachable sushi share one room, making it easy for mixed cravings at one table.