Skip to main content

Best Solo Dining Sanctuaries Restaurants in Old Town

12 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
Old Jerusalem Restaurant
Decades-old Old Town fixture for Palestinian and Middle Eastern comfort plates.

Notable Picks

$$ Old Town Mediterranean, Middle Eastern
A longtime Old Town standby since the 1970s, Old Jerusalem serves classic Palestinian and broader Middle Eastern staples in a compact, homey dining room. Locals come for plates of kebabs, shawarma, and vegetarian mezze that have stayed remarkably consistent over decades.
Must-Try Dishes: Chicken shawarma plate, Falafel sandwich, Hummus with meat
What makes it special: Decades-old Old Town fixture for Palestinian and Middle Eastern comfort plates.
$ Old Town Burgers
A focused, counter-service burger stop built around a tight menu and repeatable execution. The move is to keep it classic—one burger, fries, and a shake—because the strength here is consistency, speed, and that crisp-edged griddle profile.
Must-Try Dishes: Cheeseburger, Wagyu Truffle Burger, Shoestring Fries
What makes it special: Tight, griddle-forward burger execution with minimal decision fatigue.
$$ Old Town
Small Cheval’s Lincoln Park location brings the mini-Au Cheval burger formula to Halsted with Golden Fries served alongside garlic aioli. The space is compact but polished, and most guests treat fries plus a signature double cheeseburger as a streamlined, high-calorie ritual before or after nearby shopping and bar-hopping.
Must-Try Dishes: Golden Fries with Garlic Aioli, Signature Double Cheeseburger, Plant Based Burger with Golden Fries
What makes it special: Golden Fries with garlic aioli bring the Au Cheval-style burger-and-fries experience to a faster, more casual Lincoln Park setting.
$ Old Town Seafood
A compact Old Town room with a buzzy soundtrack and a Peru-meets-Nikkei menu that’s strongest in bright, citrus-forward lanes. Build your meal around one ceviche, one hot wok or skewer dish, and one rich rice plate to keep the pacing clean.
Must-Try Dishes: Ceviche, Lomo saltado, Smoked duck breast rice
What makes it special: Peruvian-Japanese flavors in a small, high-energy room.
$ Old Town Sandwiches
North Buena Deli & Wine’s Lincoln Park outpost works as an all-day corner deli where breakfast sandwiches, Italian subs, and wine bottles share tight shelves. It’s more bodega than café, but the under-$10 sandwiches and friendly counter service make it a reliable everyday stop.
Must-Try Dishes: The Italian Sandwich, Turkey BLT, Bacon Egg & Cheese Croissant
What makes it special: A compact deli-and-bottle-shop hybrid where solid hot and cold sandwiches stay priced like everyday lunch.
$$ Old Town Pizza
A compact Old Town counter that’s built for quick slices and straightforward pies, with a style that leans crisp and snackable. It’s best as a fast win—order a couple slices, eat them hot, and move on without turning it into a long sit-down.
Must-Try Dishes: Bob's Pepperoni Pizza, Mushroom and Onion Slice, Cheese Slice
What makes it special: A small-footprint slice shop that delivers a reliably satisfying quick hit.
$$ Old Town Chinese
Peking Chinese Food is a long-running Old Town storefront known for made-to-order Chinese-American standards, generous lunch specials, and reliable delivery. The space is basic and fluorescent, but locals lean on it for saucy General Tso’s, lo mein, and big trays of fried rice.
Must-Try Dishes: General Tso's Chicken, Chicken Lo Mein, Crab Rangoon
What makes it special: Tiny North Avenue counter spot where made-to-order Chinese takeout has anchored Old Town for years.

Worthy Picks

$ Old Town Bagels
A cozy Old Town coffeehouse where bagels function as the most dependable food lane—simple, warm, and built to pair cleanly with espresso drinks. It’s at its best when you treat the bagel as the anchor and don’t overcomplicate the order.
Must-Try Dishes: Prosciutto bagel, Everything bagel with egg and bacon, Plain bagel
What makes it special: Cozy coffeehouse bagel sandwiches in a work-friendly space.
$ Old Town American
An Old Town tavern with serious history and a smaller, more intimate feel than the neighborhood’s bigger sports bars. It’s best as a snacks-and-drinks destination where the comfort menu supports the main event: lingering over beer, wine, and conversation.
Must-Try Dishes: Potato pancakes, Schnitzel sandwich, Chicken fritters
What makes it special: Historic Old Town tavern energy with a focused food-and-drink program.
$ Old Town Pizza
Papa Romeo’s is a family-owned late-night delivery and takeout shop promising hot pizzas and cheesy bread until 5 a.m. every night. It’s the move when you want affordable, made-to-order pies and sides delivered deep into the overnight hours from a simple counter storefront.
Must-Try Dishes: Create-Your-Own Thin-Crust Pizza, Chicago Style Cheesebread, BBQ Chicken or Caprese Specialty Pizza
What makes it special: A hyper-late delivery specialist serving pizza and sides until 5 a.m.
$ Old Town Bagels, Sandwiches
A coffee-first breakfast stop where bagels show up as the most practical, grab-and-go move—warm, filling, and built for speed. Keep the order tight (one bagel + one drink) and you’ll get the best version of what the shop does well.
Must-Try Dishes: BIG BEC Brekkie Bagel, Brekkie Bagel, Bagel & spread
What makes it special: Coffee-first spot with a simple, satisfying brekkie bagel lane.
$ Old Town Pizza
A by-the-slice stop tucked under the Sedgwick Brown Line that’s built for pure convenience, not a long meal. Treat it like a commuter move: grab a couple slices while they’re hot, keep expectations focused on quick satisfaction, and get back to your night.
Must-Try Dishes: Cheese Slice, Pepperoni Slice, Slice Special (rotating)
What makes it special: Brown Line-adjacent slices designed for fast, reliable grab-and-go eating.