Skip to main content

Best Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Restaurants in St. Bens

6 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
Pete's Pizza
Decades-old neighborhood pizzeria where lasagna pans are a staple.

Notable Picks

$$ St. Bens Italian, Pizza
Serving North Center since the 1950s, Pete's Pizza pairs its thin-crust pies with baked cheese and meat lasagna trays that feel tailor-made for family dinners. The room stays casual and busy, with regulars ordering lasagna for dine-in, carryout, and catering alongside old-school pizza combinations.
Must-Try Dishes: Baked cheese lasagna, Baked meat lasagna, Thin-crust sausage pizza
What makes it special: Decades-old neighborhood pizzeria where lasagna pans are a staple.
$ St. Bens Mediterranean, Middle Eastern
Tucked into a strip mall near Lane Tech, Pi-Hi blends shawarma plates, falafel, and wood-fired “Pi” pizzas into one of the area’s best low-cost Mediterranean options. National attention from Yelp’s Top 100 list and steady crowds for takeout underline its status as a long-running neighborhood favorite.
Must-Try Dishes: Mediterranean Pizza Pi with shawarma, Chicken shawarma plate, Falafel plate with hummus and salad
What makes it special: Strip-mall Mediterranean cafe known for shawarma, generous portions, and hybrid pizzas.

Worthy Picks

St. Bens Mexican
Run by a Salvadoran-Nicaraguan family, this tiny North Center storefront specializes in griddled pupusas alongside tacos and other antojitos. The space is simple, but the masa work and house salsas draw a steady stream of regulars.
Must-Try Dishes: Cheese and loroco pupusas, Revuelta pupusas, Tacos de asada
What makes it special: Compact counter-service spot where fresh pupusas and tacos are griddled to order.
$ St. Bens American, Wings
O’Donovan’s is a historic North Center pub with a big beer garden, sports on TV, and a menu of burgers, bar snacks, and simple American plates. It’s more about atmosphere and convenience than chef-y food, but locals lean on it for casual group outings and neighborhood hangs.
Must-Try Dishes: O'Donovan's Burger, Mini Turkey Burgers, Tater Tots
What makes it special: Old-school trolley-line pub with a roomy beer garden and TVs.
$ St. Bens Greek
Since the late 1990s, Big Boy Gyros has been a Roscoe Village/North Center standby for classic Chicago-style gyros, Greek fries, and char-grilled burgers. It’s a no-frills counter where portions are big, prices stay low, and the menu runs from breakfast omelettes to late-afternoon gyro plates.
Must-Try Dishes: Big Boy Gyros Sandwich, Gyros Plate, Gyros Omelette
What makes it special: Long-running Greek-American counter known for overstuffed gyros and Greek fries.
$ St. Bens Japanese, Sushi
A compact counter-style Japanese kitchen where the move is quick onigiri, simple rolls, and hot comfort sides for an easy grab-and-go meal. Treat it like a focused lunch stop—two onigiri plus one roll or side—so the order stays fast and satisfying.
Must-Try Dishes: Onigiri (sushi rice balls), Unagi roll, Tuna avocado roll
What makes it special: Fast, snackable Japanese comfort built around onigiri.