Best Middle Eastern Restaurants in Wicker Park

Cafe Istanbul is a Turkish-Mediterranean dining room where warm bread, doner, and Iskender kebab come out of an open kitchen to a steady crowd. It lands between neighborhood casual and occasion-worthy, with portions that often stretch to leftovers and a patio that makes it a go-to for relaxed dinners on Division.

Sultan's Market is a long-running, counter-service Middle Eastern spot (established in the mid-1990s) known for big, inexpensive falafel and shawarma wraps, salad bar boxes, and daily soups. The Wicker Park location on North Avenue draws a steady mix of neighborhood regulars and late-night crowds looking for filling plates under $15.

Elia is a modern Mediterranean restaurant on Division where mezze, mixed grills, and seafood arrive in a candlelit room accented with deep reds and live-fire aromas. It’s used for birthday dinners and date nights when diners want an all-evening experience built around shared plates and a broader wine list.

Rumi Middle Eastern Grill runs a counter-service model focused on bowls, salads, and plates built around shawarma, falafel, and grilled meats. It’s the healthier-feeling option on Milwaukee for diners who want something fast but customizable, with plenty of vegetables and spreads in the mix.

Falafel & Grill is a narrow counter spot where crisp falafel, shawarma sandwiches, and mixed plates come out fast and travel well. Wicker Park regulars treat it as a dependable late-lunch or casual dinner move when they want something filling, under $15, and clearly Middle Eastern rather than bar food.