Best Pizza Restaurants in Wicker Park

Paulie Gee’s Wicker Park runs like a classic New York slice shop, slinging 20-inch pies and creative slices into the early-morning hours on weekends. It’s where neighborhood regulars and industry folks end the night with hot honey-drizzled pepperoni or crisp grandma squares.

Paradise Park is a trailer-park-themed pizzeria and bar where tavern-style pies, frozen drinks, and loaded apps fuel loud nights on a sprawling patio. Groups use it for birthday parties and day-drinking sessions when they want playful pizza more than serious, quiet dining.

Piece is a long-running Wicker Park brewpub specializing in New Haven–style pies alongside house-brewed beers in a big, lively room. Locals rely on it for tavern tables full of red and white pizzas paired with pitchers when they want beer-first hangs that still deliver on food.

Craft Pizza is a cozy Wicker Park shop turning out New York–leaning thin-crust pies with carefully layered toppings. Nearby residents treat it as their upgraded neighborhood standby for delivery, slices, or a low-key dine-in night that still feels special.

The DiDiana family brings Neapolitan soul to Bucktown with wood-fired pizzas, fresh pastas, and recipes from their ancestral town of Acerra outside Naples. This newer addition to the neighborhood offers warm family hospitality and a charming outdoor patio.

Parlor’s Wicker Park outpost is a sprawling bar-pizza concept with big patios, loud music, and a long list of topped tavern pies. It’s less about purist pizza and more about pitchers, shots, and shareable food when your group wants a rowdy afternoon or night outdoors.