Master Critic Review
Ellen's Stardust Diner
8.5
Vibes:
Live Music Showtime
Family Friendly Favorites
Birthday & Celebration Central
Instagram Worthy Wonders
NYC's original singing waiter diner since 1987 delivers Broadway-caliber vocal performances from aspiring theater stars while serving classic American fare like the Mac n' Cheese Burger and confetti pancakes. The 1950s-themed space with its Miss Subways memorabilia and drive-in theater screen creates an immersive pre-show experience that has launched countless performers to actual Broadway stages including Wicked, Jersey Boys, and The Outsiders.
Must-Try Dishes:
Yankee Doodle Burger (Mac n' Cheese topped), Confetti Pancakes, Stardust Nachos
Scores:
Value: 7
Service: 8
Consistency: 9
Food Quality: 7
Atmosphere: 9
Cultural Relevance: 9.5
What makes it special: Broadway-caliber singing waitstaff who perform show tunes tableside—many have gone on to actual Broadway productions
Who should go: Families, theater lovers, tourists seeking NYC entertainment
When to visit: Arrive before 5pm or right after Broadway shows end
What to order: Mac n' Cheese Burger, confetti pancakes, specialty milkshakes
Insider tip: Request a song from your server—they'll often perform it if they know it
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No dedicated parking; street parking extremely difficult in Times Square area. Use nearby parking garages ($25-50) or take subway to 50th St (1 train) or 49th St (N/R/W)
Dress code: Casual - anything goes from tourist attire to theater clothes. Come comfortable as you may be clapping and singing along
Noise level: Very loud - continuous live singing performances make normal conversation difficult. Embrace the entertainment rather than expect intimate dining
Weekend wait: 45-90 minutes, especially post-Broadway shows around 10pm. Line moves steadily but expect to wait outside
Weekday lunch: 15-30 minutes typically. Before 5pm on weekdays often minimal wait
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes - Black Bean Veggie Burger, Pasta Primavera, Grilled Cheese, Mac & Cheese, Mozzarella Triangles, multiple salads
Vegan options: Limited - Pasta Primavera (request no cheese), salads without cheese, some sides. Not a strong vegan destination
Gluten-free options: Marked on menu - GF pasta available (+$2), quinoa bowl, some salads. Cross-contamination possible in busy kitchen; staff has mixed reviews on allergy handling
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Not ideal - the noise level makes conversation nearly impossible, and you'll be interrupted by performances every few minutes. Better for established couples seeking a fun, casual outing rather than getting-to-know-you conversations.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes, walk-in only - they don't take reservations. Use the Yelp Waitlist feature to hold your spot in line remotely. Entire party must be present to be seated. Best strategy: arrive right when they open at 7am, before 5pm, or immediately after Broadway shows let out.
Is it kid-friendly? Extremely - this is one of NYC's best family dining experiences. Kids menu available with chicken tenders and grilled cheese. Children love the singing performances, can dance and move around, and servers often interact with young guests. Many families describe it as an affordable alternative to Broadway for kids who can't sit through full shows.
Can I request songs? Yes - tell your server your request. Not guaranteed but they accommodate when possible. Popular Broadway numbers and Disney songs have high success rates. Some servers will even hand the mic to guests who want to sing along.
Is the food actually good? It's solid diner fare, not destination dining. You come for the entertainment, not culinary excellence. Burgers, nachos, and milkshakes are reliable choices. Set expectations for classic American comfort food at Times Square prices ($25-35 entrees).
Best For
Better for: Live entertainment dining experience, families with kids who love music, pre/post Broadway theater crowds, out-of-town visitors seeking quintessential NYC experience, aspiring Broadway fans wanting to see future stars perform
Consider Alternatives If: You want quiet conversation, serious foodie experience, quick meal, strict dietary restrictions, or you're bothered by loud environments. Also skip if you dislike musical theater - performances are constant and unavoidable