ZipPicks Awards
Best Hidden Gem Restaurants in Lincoln Square
Master Critic Review
Hilary's Cookies
7.6
A Lincoln Square baking operation that’s more ‘seek it out’ than walk-in—strong cookies and small-batch baked goods that reward pre-order planning. Treat it like a dessert supply stop: grab a mixed box, then build the rest of your night around it.
Must-Try Dishes:
Assorted cookie box, Seasonal scone, Brownie bar
Scores:
Value: 7.8
Service: 7
Consistency: 7.4
Food Quality: 8.1
Atmosphere: 6
Cultural Relevance: 6.7
What makes it special: Pre-order-first baking with a loyal local following.
Who should go: Cookie people and dessert planners
When to visit: Pick-up windows and special event days
What to order: Cookie box, seasonal scone, brownie bar
Insider tip: Check the schedule—this isn’t a reliable walk-in stop.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking only; generally manageable on side streets during daytime pickup windows, tighter during evening events.
Dress code: Casual — this is a pickup-focused bakery, no dress considerations needed.
Noise level: Very quiet — quick pickup environment rather than a sit-down space.
Weekend wait: Not applicable — availability depends on pre-orders and scheduled pickup windows rather than walk-in waits.
Weekday lunch: Minimal wait during pickup windows if pre-ordered; walk-in availability is inconsistent.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — all standard baked goods are vegetarian.
Vegan options: Limited — occasional vegan items appear, but they are not guaranteed and often sell out quickly.
Gluten-free options: Very limited — gluten-free items are occasional and not part of a fixed menu.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Not on its own — there’s no seating or linger factor, but it’s excellent as a planned dessert pickup to bring to a date or dinner elsewhere.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No — this is primarily a pre-order and pickup operation, not a sit-down bakery with tables.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes for treats — kids will love the cookies and brownies, but there are no kid-specific amenities or seating.
Best For
Better for: High-quality cookies and baked goods when you plan ahead and want dessert handled without guesswork.
Consider Alternatives If: You want an impulse walk-in bakery, a café experience, or guaranteed dietary-specific options.