Master Critic Review
Joe's Pizza
8.1
The Miami outpost of NYC's 1975 slice institution delivers the same thin, foldable, paper-plate-defying pizza that made the original famous. Stick to the classic cheese or pepperoni for the full experience—no frills needed. Late-night hours make it the go-to after exploring Wynwood.
Must-Try Dishes:
Classic Cheese Slice, Pepperoni Slice, Sicilian Square Slice
Scores:
Value: 7.8
Service: 7.5
Consistency: 8.5
Food Quality: 8.3
Atmosphere: 7.5
Cultural Relevance: 8.5
What makes it special: The Miami outpost of NYC's legendary 1975 pizzeria, serving the same thin-crust slices that fold perfectly over a paper plate.
Who should go: New Yorkers craving an authentic slice experience.
When to visit: Late night after Wynwood bar hopping—open until 5am weekends.
What to order: Keep it simple with a classic cheese or pepperoni slice—they perfect the basics so well that fancy toppings aren't necessary.
Insider tip: The Sicilian square slice with toppings is a sleeper hit that regulars swear by.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Wynwood street parking is challenging—Uber recommended. No dedicated lot
Dress code: Super casual—it's a NYC-style slice shop. Come as you are
Noise level: Counter-service with minimal indoor seating—quick in-and-out experience
Weekend wait: Fast turnaround even when busy—slices ready to go
Weekday lunch: Virtually no wait—grab and go
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Cheese slices, salads with vegetables, multiple veggie topping options
Vegan options: Not specified—limited options likely
Gluten-free options: Not recommended for Celiac—flour in the air, not a GF establishment
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? No - this is a fast-casual slice shop, not a sit-down date spot. Counter seating and a few tables inside, but most people grab slices to eat while walking Wynwood. Better for a spontaneous late-night snack than a planned date.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes - no reservations needed. It's fast-casual ordering at the counter. Even when busy, you'll be holding a slice in minutes. Open extremely late (until 3-5am depending on the day).
Is it kid-friendly? Yes - described as 'kid-friendly but not kiddy.' Simple pizza slices are perfect for kids, and the casual atmosphere accommodates families. No specific info on high chairs, so bring a carrier for toddlers.
Is it good for groups? Yes for casual group outings - the format works well for grabbing slices together while bar-hopping or exploring Wynwood. Limited indoor seating means larger groups may eat standing or outside.
Is there outdoor seating? Yes - outdoor seating available on NW 25th Street. Also dog-friendly, making it easy to grab a slice with pets.
Best For
Better for: Authentic NYC foldable slices open until 3-5am. Best late-night pizza option in Wynwood. Simple, crispy, classic
Consider Alternatives If: Need gluten-free options or a sit-down dining experience—this is grab-and-go
Hours
Monday11am - 3am
Tuesday11am - 3am
Wednesday11am - 3am
Thursday11am - 4am
Friday11am - 5am
Saturday11am - 5am
Sunday11am - 3am