Loretta & The Butcher
Closed
Website
Master Critic Review
Loretta & The Butcher
7.9
An owner-operated neighborhood parrilla where the kitchen keeps it tight — coarse salt, imported Argentine cuts, and a live fire that does the work without leaning on sauces or technique theater. The empanadas and sweetbreads reliably anchor the table before the skirt steak takes over, and BOGO wine nights on Mondays and Tuesdays add real pull for repeat visits. The elevated outdoor deck on Commodore Plaza turns a casual dinner into something that lingers, backed by staff who know regulars by name.
Must-Try Dishes:
Entraña 14 oz (Skirt Steak), Arroz del Gaucho, Empanadas
Scores:
Value: 8.2
Service: 8.3
Consistency: 8
Food Quality: 7.8
Atmosphere: 7.5
Cultural Relevance: 7.5
What makes it special: Intimate, owner-operated neighborhood parrilla born from a wine trip to Mendoza, with premium Argentine-imported cuts cooked over fire with nothing but coarse salt — the antithesis of corporate steakhouse pomp.
Who should go: Locals craving genuine Argentine warmth without the price tag
When to visit: Monday or Tuesday for BOGO wine bottle nights
What to order: Start with empanadas and the mollejas, then split the Butcher Parrillada for a full sampling of the grill — the Arroz del Gaucho is the sleeper hit most tables wish they'd ordered, so add it as a shared side.
Insider tip: Grab a sidewalk patio seat for the best vibe, and ask the owner about the curated Argentine wine list — they're genuinely passionate about pairings.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No dedicated lot—street parking on Commodore Plaza and surrounding streets. Commodore Lot (3121 Commodore Plz, 220 spaces) and Florentine Plaza lot (3105 Commodore Plz, 185 spaces) are both within a 1-2 minute walk. Private lots run $6-10/hr. Rideshare recommended on weekend evenings.
Dress code: Smart casual but relaxed—think nice jeans, a collared shirt or casual dress. The vibe is cozy neighborhood bistro, not stuffy. You'll see everything from date-night outfits to families in casual wear.
Noise level: Warm and conversational—not loud. The small dining room has a Buenos Aires bistro feel where you can comfortably talk across the table. The elevated outdoor deck on Commodore Plaza has a pleasant street-side hum without being overwhelming.
Weekend wait: Reservations recommended—this is a neighborhood gem that fills up. Expect 20-30 min waits without one on Fri/Sat.
Weekday lunch: Open Mon-Fri starting at noon. Minimal wait, easy to walk in for lunch.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Moderate options—risotto (asparagus and mushroom is a standout), salads including Ensalada Griega, roasted cauliflower, and grilled vegetables. Enough to build a satisfying meal.
Vegan options: Limited—salads and grilled vegetables can work, but much of the menu relies on dairy and animal fats. Call ahead to confirm what the kitchen can accommodate.
Gluten-free options: Not specifically labeled. Grilled meats, salads, and vegetables are naturally gluten-free. Call ahead to confirm for strict dietary needs.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Yes — this is one of Coconut Grove's better low-key date night options. Reviewers consistently describe it as cozy, intimate, and warm without being pretentious. The indoor dining room has charming decor and a neighborhood-bistro feel, while the sidewalk patio adds an easygoing, romantic touch on pleasant evenings. Noise levels stay comfortable for conversation. BOGO wine nights on Mondays and Tuesdays make for an especially great value date. The overall vibe is relaxed Argentine steakhouse — dressed-up enough to feel special but casual enough to feel comfortable.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Walk-ins are possible, especially on weekday lunches and early evenings — one reviewer noted walking in on a Sunday for lunch with no wait. However, the restaurant recommends reservations, and weekend dinner hours (particularly Friday and Saturday) can fill up given its popularity as a neighborhood favorite. Book through their website or reservation platforms 2–3 days ahead for weekend dinners to be safe.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes — families are genuinely welcome here. The restaurant has a dedicated kids' menu (confirmed via delivery platforms), and reviewers describe bringing children with positive experiences (one family dined with a 12-year-old and called it a fantastic experience). The casual noise level and relaxed atmosphere mean kids won't feel out of place. Outdoor sidewalk seating is pet-friendly and gives families more breathing room. Brunch on weekends (Sat-Sun starting 11am) is a particularly good option for families.
Is it good for groups? Manageable for medium groups, but not ideal for very large parties. The restaurant is a quaint, boutique-sized space — mostly 2-4 top tables with some larger configurations. They do not advertise private rooms and reportedly do not accept private party bookings. Larger groups may be accommodated on a case-by-case basis with advance notice. They do offer catering for offsite events. For groups of 6+, call (786) 618-9982 ahead to confirm seating options.
Is there outdoor seating? Yes — the sidewalk/outdoor patio is one of the restaurant's highlights. Reviewers frequently praise the outdoor dining experience, describing it as lovely and charming with great Grove-side ambiance. The patio is dog-friendly. It's not covered or climate-controlled, so it's best enjoyed during cooler evening hours or pleasant weather. Multiple reviewers specifically recommended sitting outside when possible.
Best For
Better for: The relaxed, unpretentious neighborhood feel—this is where locals go, not tourists. Outstanding value with BOGO wine bottles on Mondays and Tuesdays, and the earliest happy hour in the Grove (3-6 PM weekdays). The elevated outdoor deck is one of the most charming patios in Coconut Grove. Dog-friendly.
Skip if: You want a polished, upscale steakhouse experience or a large group setting. This is a small, intimate spot—not ideal for parties over 8. Dessert menu has been noted as a weak point compared to the rest of the experience.
Hours
Monday12pm - 10pm
Tuesday12pm - 10pm
Wednesday12pm - 10pm
Thursday12pm - 10pm
Friday12pm - 11pm
Saturday11am - 11pm
Sunday11am - 10pm