Best Group Dining Gatherings Mexican Restaurants in Westchester
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Cinco
Oaxacan-inspired burritos paired with one of the area’s deeper mezcal lists.
Notable Picks
#1
Cinco
8.6
Cinco is an Oaxacan-leaning neighborhood restaurant and bar where the burrito section shares the spotlight with mezcal, craft beer, and thoughtful small plates. Burritos come with well-seasoned meats, black beans, and salsa borracha, in a space that works as well for date night as it does for a mezcal-heavy group hang.
Must-Try Dishes:
Burrito with Al Pastor, Burrito Vegetal, Tacos al Carbon
What Makes it Special: Oaxacan-inspired burritos paired with one of the area’s deeper mezcal lists.
8.2
Paco’s is a long-standing cantina famous for handmade tortillas, jumbo burritos, and strong margaritas, serving until about 10pm most nights.【3†turn3search3】 With over 3,400 aggregated reviews and a menu heavy on combo plates and soups, it’s a dependable sit-down choice for late-ish dinners and group outings.【3†turn3search23】【6†turn6search7】
Must-Try Dishes:
Supermex Burrito, Albondigas soup, Combination enchilada and taco plate
What Makes it Special: Hearty, old-school platters with handmade tortillas and big margaritas.
8.1
A Westchester staple since 1973, Hacienda Del Rey serves classic combination plates, fajitas, and strong margaritas in a lively, slightly old-school dining room that runs to about 10–11pm on weekends.【3†turn3search2】【5†turn5search5】 While its review volume is modest compared with some neighbors, decades of local affection and consistently warm service keep it firmly in the late-night rotation.
Must-Try Dishes:
Shredded beef enchiladas with red sauce, Fajitas Del Rey, Albondigas soup
What Makes it Special: Decades-old neighborhood mainstay with generous plates and strong margaritas.