Best Hidden Gems Pizza Restaurants in Wynwood
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Fradiavolo
Italy's Top 25 ranked pizzeria brought its first US location to Wynwood, with dough made and shipped fresh from Italy using mineral-rich water and four crust options including signature charcoal-infused black dough.
Notable Picks
#1
Fradiavolo
8.4
Italy's Top 25-ranked pizzeria chain planted its first U.S. flag in Wynwood in late 2024, importing dough made with mineral-rich Italian water and offering four crust styles including a striking charcoal-infused black option. The blistered, airy crusts earn their reputation—particularly on the La Diva with prosciutto, burrata, and fig jam—though the operation's newness means the kitchen is still finding its footing with consistency during peak hours. Vintage Italian furniture, stacked records, and decorative bikes create a casual-cool space that matches the playful 'Eat Pizza. Make Love' tagline without trying too hard. Come here when you want legitimately excellent Neapolitan pizza without the pretense of a tasting-menu experience.
Must-Try Dishes:
La Diva (Prosciutto, Burrata & Fig Jam), Margherita with Fiordilatte, Mortazza Tua (Pistachio Mortadella & Burrata)
What Makes it Special: Italy's Top 25 ranked pizzeria brought its first US location to Wynwood, with dough made and shipped fresh from Italy using mineral-rich water and four crust options including signature charcoal-infused black dough.
Worthy Picks
7.7
Collaboration between Brooklyn's Best Pizza owner and Gramps bar serves respectable NY-style slices from a Cuban-style ventanita window on a dive bar patio. The weekday lunch deal of two slices and a drink makes it a neighborhood standby. Quality can vary, but the setting—grabbing pizza while friends drink on the patio—captures the Wynwood vibe.
Must-Try Dishes:
El Queso Classic Slice, La Blanca White Pie, La Hawaiiana
What Makes it Special: A collaboration between Brooklyn's Best Pizza owner and Gramps bar, serving obsessively loved NY-style slices in a dive bar patio setting.
7.6
Family-owned brick oven operation where the hot honey pepperoni draws regulars willing to drive across town for the smoky char. Counter service in a compact space with street art decor keeps the vibe casual and quick. Solid neighborhood option when Wynwood's trendier pizza spots have long waits.
Must-Try Dishes:
Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza, White Truffle Pizza, Margherita
What Makes it Special: Family-owned brick oven pizzeria where skilled locals tend the fire, imparting a unique smoky flavor to each artisanal pie.