0 Followers
Milly's Pizza In The Pan
Master Critic Review
Milly's Pizza In The Pan
8.1
Milly's is a cult pan-pizza shop baking towering, slow-baked pies with caramelized crusts and intricate topping combos. Fans treat it like a special-occasion pickup: you plan ahead, grab your pre-ordered pie, and take it home for a deep-dish night that feels engineered rather than improvised.
Must-Try Dishes:
Only Pans, Craigslist.org, Clickbait
Scores:
Value: 7.6
Service: 7
Consistency: 8.4
Food Quality: 9.2
Atmosphere: 6.5
Cultural Relevance: 8.6
What makes it special: Cult-status pan pies with intricate toppings and caramelized edges.
Who should go: Deep-dish obsessives willing to pre-order limited pies.
When to visit: Evenings before sellout; plan ahead for pickup windows.
What to order: Only Pans, Craigslist.org, Clickbait.
Insider tip: Order days ahead for weekends; walk-up availability is rare.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking in the neighborhood; spots can be limited during dinner hours
Dress code: Casual – you’re picking up pizza, so anything goes
Noise level: Low – this is primarily a pickup operation rather than a sit-down restaurant
Weekend wait: Pre-order days in advance; same-day availability is unlikely
Weekday lunch: Pickup available only during set pre-order windows; no typical lunch service
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes – several pies can be ordered vegetarian or customized
Vegan options: Limited – not a dedicated vegan operation
Gluten-free options: No gluten-free pan pizza option currently offered
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Yes, but as a take-home deep-dish night rather than a dine-in experience. Order ahead and plan a cozy evening.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No – this is primarily a pickup-only pizza shop. Expect to grab your pre-ordered pie and go.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes for takeout at home – the pizzas are rich, shareable, and great for families. On-site space is minimal.
Best For
Better for: High-concept pan pies with caramelized edges and creative toppings that feel engineered and special-occasion worthy
Skip if: You want quick slices, casual dine-in, or flexible last-minute ordering without pre-planning