0 Followers
New York Pizza
Master Critic Reviews (4 Lists)
New York Pizza
7.8
This corner pizzeria has anchored north Main Street since 1992, serving authentic New York-style thin crust by the slice or whole pie until late night. Known for generous toppings including 12 oz of steak on medium pizzas, they stay open until 2am on weekends for the late-night crowd.
Must-Try Dishes:
Brooklyn Bridge Special, By-the-Slice Pepperoni, Steak Pizza
Scores:
Value: 8.4
Service: 7.5
Consistency: 7.8
Food Quality: 7.9
Atmosphere: 6.8
Cultural Relevance: 8.2
What makes it special: Authentic NY-style open until 2am weekends
Who should go: Night owls and slice seekers
When to visit: Late night after downtown events
What to order: Single slices, Brooklyn Bridge special, calzones
Insider tip: Free party room available for birthday celebrations
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking on Main/Spring corner, metered until 6pm then free, easier after 10pm
Dress code: Anything goes - drunk college kids to construction workers, pure counter service
Noise level: Basic pizzeria acoustics - fine for casual chat but nothing romantic
Weekend wait: 5-10 min for slices, 20-30 min for whole pies
Weekday lunch: Slices ready immediately, 15-20 min for fresh pizza
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes - standard veggie pizza options available
Vegan options: No - no vegan cheese option available
Gluten-free options: Yes - rice flour GF crust available, thin and crispy style
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you're 22 and it's 1am after the bars. The fluorescent lighting and basic tables scream 'quick bite' not romance.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No reservations needed ever - it's mostly takeout with some basic tables, counter order only.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes during the day - free party room available, kid-friendly prices. Avoid late nights when the bar crowd arrives.
Best For
Better for: The only legit late-night pizza option open until 2am weekends - perfect for post-bar food with huge loaded slices under $5
Skip if: You want ambiance or gourmet quality - head to Zachary's or Much Ado for an actual dining experience
New York Pizza
8.4
Vibes:
Late Night Legends
Quick Bites Champions
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Solo Dining Sanctuaries
Downtown counter spot known for big, foldable slices and late-night hours. Since 1992, locals lean on it for quick walk-up slices, solid whole pies, and speedy delivery after Main Street events.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pepperoni slice, Garlic knots, Meat Lovers pie
Scores:
Value: 9
Service: 8.2
Consistency: 8.7
Food Quality: 8.6
Atmosphere: 6.6
Cultural Relevance: 8.3
What makes it special: True slice-shop pacing with downtown-late hours.
Who should go: Night owls and slice chasers
When to visit: Fri–Sat after 10pm for late-night service
What to order: Pepperoni slice, cheese slice, garlic knots
Insider tip: Order a slice first—whole pie bakes finish fast if you want more.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking along Main Street and adjacent public lots are free after 6pm, but spots fill quickly during weekend events.
Dress code: Casual—come as you are from a walk downtown or post-game outing.
Noise level: Moderate to lively, especially late evenings when crowds grab slices after bars close.
Weekend wait: 5–10 minutes for slices, 15–20 minutes for whole pies at peak hours.
Weekday lunch: Usually no wait—quick counter turnover.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes—cheese, veggie, and white-sauce options are regularly available by the slice.
Vegan options: Limited—no vegan cheese, but you can request veggie toppings on sauce-only pies.
Gluten-free options: No gluten-free crusts; best to look elsewhere for dietary needs.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only if you’re keeping it casual—perfect for a late slice and a stroll, not a sit-down vibe.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes, seating is first-come, counter-style with a few small tables—reservations aren’t taken.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes for older kids who can handle a quick counter setup, though seating is limited and late-night crowds can be loud.
Best For
Better for: Late-night slices, quick service, and grab-and-go convenience when other spots have closed.
Skip if: You want a full-service meal, quiet dining, or gluten-free pizza options.
New York Pizza
8.4
Vibes:
Late Night Legends
Quick Bites Champions
Family Friendly Favorites
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Downtown slice shop known for fast counter service and late-night hours, with whole pies and hefty slices. Locals lean on reliable delivery and quick walk-up orders after events on Main Street.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pepperoni Slice, Garlic Knots, Meat Lovers Pie
Scores:
Value: 9
Service: 7.9
Consistency: 8.2
Food Quality: 8.4
Atmosphere: 6.8
Cultural Relevance: 8.5
What makes it special: Open-late slices and pies with speedy counter and delivery.
Who should go: Night owls and downtown event-goers
When to visit: Fri–Sat after 10pm for true late-night service
What to order: Pepperoni slice, garlic knots, meat lovers pie
Insider tip: Order a slice first—whole pie bakes finish fast if you want more.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking along Main Street is free after 6pm but can be limited during downtown events. The public lot on Angela Street usually has open spaces after 9pm.
Dress code: Casual—most customers arrive in jeans, hoodies, or game-day gear.
Noise level: Moderate to lively—music and foot traffic from nearby bars, but conversation is easy indoors.
Weekend wait: 5–10 minutes for slices, 15–20 minutes for whole pies at peak hours.
Weekday lunch: No wait for slices, 10 minutes for custom pies.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes—multiple veggie pizzas and salads available.
Vegan options: Limited—can build a cheese-free veggie pie upon request.
Gluten-free options: No dedicated crust or prep area; cross-contact possible.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Better for casual meetups or post-event bites than formal dates. Quick counter service and shared slices keep it light and easy.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes—this is a counter-service setup. Grab a table if one’s open or take your order to-go.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes—families frequent it before or after Main Street events. Booth seating and short waits make it easy for kids.
Best For
Better for: Late-night convenience and quick turnaround beat nearby sit-down pizzerias.
Skip if: You’re looking for artisan pies, table service, or craft beer pairings—opt for a full-service pizzeria instead.
New York Pizza
7.8
Counter-service slices and whole pies right on Main Street, open late most nights. Families use it for fast, affordable meals before or after downtown events.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pepperoni Slice, Cheese Pie, Garlic Knots
Scores:
Value: 8.6
Service: 7.6
Consistency: 7.7
Food Quality: 7.8
Atmosphere: 6.8
Cultural Relevance: 7.5
What makes it special: Late-hours slices and fast service on Main Street.
Who should go: Budget-minded families downtown
When to visit: After events when nearby lots reopen
What to order: Pepperoni slice, Cheese pie, Garlic knots
Insider tip: Grab slices first—whole pies follow quickly if you’re still hungry.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking along Main Street and nearby side streets; public lots open up after dinner rush.
Dress code: Casual and relaxed—come as you are from downtown events or errands.
Noise level: Moderate during peak hours with steady foot traffic; quieter mid-afternoon and early evening.
Weekend wait: Minimal—most orders are takeout or fast counter service; quick turnover even when busy.
Weekday lunch: Usually no wait; slices ready immediately and pies within 10–15 minutes.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes—classic cheese, veggie, and customizable topping options.
Vegan options: Limited—no vegan cheese, but you can request sauce-only or veggie-loaded pies.
Gluten-free options: Not currently offered; standard wheat crust only.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Better for a casual slice-and-stroll vibe than a sit-down date—it’s quick, inexpensive, and centrally located downtown.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes—no reservations are taken. Small tables turn quickly and most guests eat on the go.
Is it kid-friendly? Definitely—counter service is quick, prices are low, and nearby sidewalks make stroller access easy.
Best For
Better for: Late-night eats and grab-and-go slices when other Main Street options have closed.
Skip if: You’re looking for a sit-down family dinner or gourmet toppings—try Gay Nineties or Parktown Pizza instead.