Skip to main content

Best Sandwiches Restaurants in Bath Beach

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
The Original John's Deli
Long-running Brooklyn hero shop known for roast beef and gravy.

Notable Picks

$ Bath Beach Sandwiches
Family-owned since 1968, The Original John's Deli is a Gravesend institution built around overstuffed hot and cold heroes, especially roast beef with gravy. Thousands of reviews across platforms point to it as a go-to for classic Brooklyn sandwiches, generous portions, and reliable takeout.
Must-Try Dishes: Johnny Roast Beef hero, Chicken parmigiana hero, Potato croquettes
What makes it special: Long-running Brooklyn hero shop known for roast beef and gravy.

Worthy Picks

$ Bath Beach American, Bagels
A small corner deli that doubles as a practical breakfast-and-lunch stop, best used for tight ordering: one bagel or breakfast sandwich and one coffee, then move on. It’s a neighborhood utility play—simple, repeatable, and built for grab-and-go rhythm.
Must-Try Dishes: Bagel with cream cheese, Eggs with potato and cheese sandwich, Cream cheese and lox bagel
What makes it special: Corner deli execution that’s built for fast, practical breakfast wins.
$$$$ Bath Beach Sandwiches
A convenient deli-and-grill format that works best for simple, hot-off-the-grill sandwich runs when you want something fast without fuss. Keep the order focused and treat it as a utility stop—execution reads best on straightforward deli classics.
Must-Try Dishes: Grilled Chicken Sandwich, Philly Cheesesteak, Chopped Cheese
What makes it special: All-day deli-grill utility for fast, hot sandwiches.