Best Pizza Restaurants in Bensonhurst
4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Il Colosseo
Brick-oven cooking with a classic Italian dining-room feel.
Notable Picks
#1
Il Colosseo
8.4
A cozy, brick-oven Italian restaurant with a true neighborhood dining-room cadence—best approached as a classic progression of one appetizer, one pasta, and a main. It shines when you commit to the oven and the red-sauce fundamentals rather than spreading across the entire menu.
Must-Try Dishes:
Brick-oven pizza, Pasta alla Frank Sinatra, Tiramisu
What Makes it Special: Brick-oven cooking with a classic Italian dining-room feel.
Worthy Picks
A neighborhood pizzeria with a broad old-school menu where the pizza lane is the cleanest way to win—especially if you stick to one specialty pie and one classic baseline. It’s a reliable local utility spot when you order like a regular and avoid over-customizing.
Must-Try Dishes:
Vodka Sauce Pizza Pie, Sicilian "Square" Pizza Pie, Stuffed Pizza Slice
What Makes it Special: Classic neighborhood pizzeria range with strong specialty-pie options.
#3
Pizza Den
7.8
Vibes:
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Quick Bites Champions
Late Night Legends
Family Friendly Favorites
A classic neighborhood pizzeria that works best as a late, practical option—grab slices, a simple pie, and one side that travels well. The menu is broad, but the happiest orders stay anchored in pizza plus one add-on, not a full spread.
Must-Try Dishes:
Cheese slice, Buffalo chicken slice, Calzone
What Makes it Special: Late-friendly neighborhood pizzeria with a dependable slice counter.
7.6
Vibes:
Quick Bites Champions
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Solo Dining Sanctuaries
Family Friendly Favorites
A Bath Beach slice-and-delivery shop that works best as a simple, efficient pizza run rather than a deep menu exploration. Keep the order tight—one pan pizza style or a couple of slices plus knots—and it delivers the most reliable value.
Must-Try Dishes:
Cheese Pizza Slice, Sicilian Pizza Slice, Chicken & Broccoli Pan Pizza
What Makes it Special: Straightforward slice shop with a strong pan-pizza and delivery lane.