Skip to main content

Best Trendy Restaurants in Bensonhurst

6 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Save
Our Top Pick
Osaka Fusion Sushi
High-volume sushi with a deep menu that stays reliable.

Notable Picks

$$ Bensonhurst Japanese, Ramen
A high-volume 86th Street sushi-and-Japanese-kitchen workhorse that wins on breadth and repeatability rather than refinement. Order best by locking into a tight lane—premium nigiri/sashimi or a focused roll set—then add one hot item if you want a fuller meal.
Must-Try Dishes: Wagyu beef sushi, Toro uni sushi, Shrimp tempura roll
What Makes it Special: High-volume sushi with a deep menu that stays reliable.
$$ Bensonhurst Middle Eastern
A Turkish kitchen that hits best when you lean into the oven-and-kebab lane: pide, grilled meats, and the kind of savory, filling plates that travel well. The menu is broad, but the highest payoff comes from ordering like a regular—one baked specialty, one grill plate, and a sweet finish.
Must-Try Dishes: Filet mignon pide, Adana kebab, Lahmacun
What Makes it Special: Turkish oven specialties and kebabs that reward focused ordering.
8.1
$$$$ Bensonhurst
A lively Shanghainese spot where the anime decor matches the energy of the room, and the dumpling lane is the reason to show up. Keep the order focused—XLB plus one crispy-bottom bun or dim sum add-on—and it lands as a trendy, repeatable neighborhood hit.
Must-Try Dishes: Xiao long bao (soup dumplings), Pan-fried juicy buns, Sticky rice shumai
What Makes it Special: Shanghainese dumplings with crisp-bottom texture and high-energy vibe.
$ Bensonhurst
A crowded, date-friendly noodle shop built around Yunnan “crossing bridge” bowls and bold broths. The best experience is a disciplined one: pick a signature noodle soup, add one cold side for contrast, and skip menu sprawl.
Must-Try Dishes: Yunnan rice noodle soup (crossing bridge style), Spicy beef brisket noodles, Wood ear mushroom salad
What Makes it Special: Broth-driven Yunnan noodle bowls with a bustling, modern room.

Worthy Picks

$$ Bensonhurst American, Burgers
A new-school burger shop that leans into smash-style satisfaction and a menu designed for fast, punchy orders. The best results come from choosing one signature burger build and backing it up with one crisp side—not assembling a whole sampler board.
Must-Try Dishes: Steak burger, Spicy fried chicken sandwich, Mozzarella sticks
What Makes it Special: Smash-burger-first shop built for quick, high-satisfaction orders.
$ Bensonhurst
A modern Hong Kong-style cafe that’s quietly become a local stop for shaved ice, slushies, and casual comfort plates. The best orders stay focused on the cold-dessert lane, where the textures and toppings hit with the most consistency.
Must-Try Dishes: Traditional shaved ice with toppings, Fruit slushy drink, HK-style cafe comfort plate
What Makes it Special: HK-style shaved ice and slushies with a modern neighborhood vibe.