Skip to main content

Best Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Tacos Restaurants in East Harlem

6 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
Taco Mix
Iconic East Harlem taqueria built around carved-to-order al pastor.

Notable Picks

8.7
$ East Harlem Japanese, Mexican
Tiny, perpetually busy East Harlem taqueria where carved-to-order al pastor is the main event and lines run late into the night. The menu stays tight—tacos, quesadillas, and a few plates—but execution and salsa variety make it a citywide taco destination. Expect to stand at the counter and eat quickly while the next round is sliced from the trompo.
Must-Try Dishes: Al pastor tacos, Barbacoa tacos, Flor de calabaza quesadilla
What makes it special: Iconic East Harlem taqueria built around carved-to-order al pastor.

Worthy Picks

$ East Harlem Mexican, Tacos
Homey East Harlem spot where tacos, rice bowls, and quesadillas read more like home cooking than fast food. The menu mixes straightforward pastor and chorizo with composed bowls and daily specials, and service leans friendly if a bit stretched at busy times. It’s a comfortable middle ground between a pure taqueria and a sit-down restaurant, especially for nearby residents.
Must-Try Dishes: Al pastor tacos, Tinga quesadilla, Mom’s style rice bowl
What makes it special: Neighborhood taqueria-café blending tacos with rice bowls and daily specials.
$ East Harlem Mexican, Tacos
Operating out of El Tepeyac Market, Dalila's Tacos centers on hefty huaraches, tacos, and stews in a no-frills setting. It shines as a low-cost, flavor-first option when you want Mexico City–style antojitos and tacos without table-service formality.
Must-Try Dishes: Huarache with cecina, Taco de carne enchilada, Taco de bistec
What makes it special: Market-adjacent taco counter known for oversized huaraches and straightforward tacos at friendly prices.
$ East Harlem Mexican, Tacos
Compact 2nd Avenue spot focused on birria and Baja-style tacos, running to midnight on weekdays and 1am on weekends. It leans heavily on delivery and takeout, but counter service stays friendly, so a couple of birria or fish tacos here is an easy late-night move when you’re north of 110th.
Must-Try Dishes: Taco De Birria, Baja Fish Tacos, Carnitas taco
What makes it special: Birria-first taco shop with delivery-friendly hours into the night.
$ East Harlem Mexican, Tacos
Narrow taco shop on Second Avenue that keeps a tight menu of tacos, burritos, and enchiladas built on fresh salsas and generous portions. The space is small but warmer than it looks from outside, with a handful of tables and quick turn on takeout orders. It’s a strong everyday option when you want a burrito or plate with rice and beans rather than a full restaurant experience.
Must-Try Dishes: Al pastor tacos with pineapple, Chicken mole enchiladas, Al pastor burrito
What makes it special: Since 2012, a locals’ go-to for affordable tacos and burritos.
$ East Harlem Mexican, Tacos
Quesadillas Doña Maty is a late-night East Harlem standby built around handmade quesadillas, tacos, and huaraches served deep into the night. It’s where you go after bars or long shifts when you want hot tortillas, straightforward fillings, and almost no wait.
Must-Try Dishes: Chicken tinga quesadilla, Taco de carnitas, Huarache con bistec
What makes it special: Late-night quesadilla and taco spot that keeps handmade tortillas and classic fillings running past midnight.