Best Seafood Restaurants in Financial District-Battery Park City
4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Number One Caviar
Focused caviar and seafood tastings with guided pairings in a tiny Wall Street boutique space.
Notable Picks
8.2
Number One Caviar is an intimate Wall Street tasting room specializing in caviar, seafood, and wine pairings rather than full entrées. Guests book it for structured caviar flights, champagne pairings, and seafood courses built around Hokkaido scallops and other premium ingredients.
Must-Try Dishes:
Caviar tasting flight with traditional accompaniments, Hokkaido scallop with champagne sauce, Kaluga caviar bump with chilled vodka
What Makes it Special: Focused caviar and seafood tastings with guided pairings in a tiny Wall Street boutique space.
8
The Full Shilling is a longstanding Irish pub in the Wall Street area where hearty pub dishes share the menu with salmon plates and a popular beer-battered fish and chips. Regulars lean on it for generous portions, friendly service, and a crowded barroom that works as well after work as it does on game days.
Must-Try Dishes:
Beer-battered fish and chips with tartar sauce, Salmon BLT on sourdough, Salmon filet with crusted goat cheese
What Makes it Special: Classic FiDi Irish pub with standout fish and chips and salmon plates in a historic barroom.
Worthy Picks
7.7
Seamore’s Lobster Shack inside The Hungry Pearl food hall is a bar-anchored counter where East Coast oysters, shrimp cocktails, and lobster rolls pair with a short list of beach-leaning snacks and cocktails. It functions as the seafood and drinks hub of the hall, turning post-work trivia nights and casual meet-ups into something closer to a low-key seafood happy hour.
Must-Try Dishes:
Local East Coast oysters, Lobster roll, Grilled shrimp tacos
What Makes it Special: Seafood-focused bar inside a modern food hall, emphasizing oysters and cocktails.
7.6
Terrace Fish & Chips is a narrow Pearl Street counter spot specializing in fried and grilled seafood platters built around flounder, shrimp, and scallops with fries or rice. Regulars lean on it as an inexpensive, no-nonsense way to get a hot seafood plate at lunch without leaving the Financial District.
Must-Try Dishes:
Fried flounder with fries, Classic fish and chips, Grilled salmon and shrimp platter
What Makes it Special: Straightforward fried and grilled seafood platters at true FiDi lunch-break prices.