Best Date Night Magic Italian Restaurants in Forest Hills

Old-school Italian in the best way—white-tablecloth comfort, generous hospitality, and a menu that leans into familiar favorites done with care. It’s the kind of place locals use for milestones, with a steady hand on pastas, seafood, and rich starters.

A polished, special-occasion Italian that leans classic—seafood, pastas, and well-executed antipasti—served in a dining room built for lingering. It’s strongest when you go the traditional route: start with a serious appetizer, pick a signature pasta or fish, and finish with an Italian dessert.

A newer Forest Hills Italian that’s winning locals with a warm, owner-forward room and food that leans handmade—especially pastas—without feeling heavy. It’s a strong pick when you want modern neighborhood Italian with a little more finesse than a standard red-sauce stop.