Best Pizza Restaurants in Forest Hills

A Forest Hills destination for brick-oven thin crust that rewards ordering a focused pie (or two) and letting the char and sauce balance do the work. It’s built for sit-down pacing—salads and classic Italian starters land best when you keep the table tight and pizza-forward.

A modern Austin Street slice-and-pie shop that leans into higher-quality builds without turning precious. It’s strongest when you order like a regular: one signature pie or a couple standout slices, then keep the rest of the order minimal so crust and cheese stay crisp.

A classic neighborhood slice shop where the smart order is targeted: one standout specialty slice and one simple baseline slice for comparison. It’s best as a quick hit—grab, go, and avoid turning it into a complicated multi-item order.

A neighborhood pizzeria that works best when you keep expectations in the NYC-slice lane: solid classics, fast turnaround, and a reliable stop when you want pizza without fuss. Go for the simplest slices and judge it on crust, sauce, and heat—not novelty.

A straightforward neighborhood pizzeria that delivers best when you order in the classic New York register: a couple of slices or a simple pie, no detours. It’s built for families and locals who want consistent comfort over trend-driven toppings.