Best Comfort Food Pizza Restaurants in Gramercy
4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Lunetta Pizza & Restaurant
Late-night slice reliability with a big, varied pie-and-slice lineup.
Notable Picks
8.2
A classic neighborhood slice-and-delivery shop that wins late because it stays open deep into the night and keeps the pizza hot, fast, and consistent. The best move is to lean into their sturdier slices that hold up after midnight, then add one simple side and call it.
Must-Try Dishes:
Grandma slice, Chicken vodka slice, White slice
What Makes it Special: Late-night slice reliability with a big, varied pie-and-slice lineup.
8
A neighborhood pizzeria that’s strongest when you order clean and classic—well-executed slices and solid pies that work for late cravings without turning into a production. Aim for their most consistent slice styles and skip over-customizing if you’re ordering late.
Must-Try Dishes:
White slice, Chicken bacon ranch slice, Classic cheese pie
What Makes it Special: Late-night pizza that stays consistent across slices and pies.
Worthy Picks
#3
Lucia Pizza
7.8
A Gramercy slice counter built for crisp, modern NYC slices with a few standout specialty options that reward a selective order. Go for one clean classic slice, then add a single signature specialty so the textures stay sharp and the meal doesn’t sprawl.
Must-Try Dishes:
Plain slice, Field Pig slice, Potato and Onion slice
What Makes it Special: A sharp slice program with a standout specialty rotation.
7.6
Vibes:
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Quick Bites Champions
Solo Dining Sanctuaries
Comfort Food Classics
A no-frills Gramercy counter built for the simplest kind of cheap pizza: a sturdy slice, quick service, and you’re back out the door. It’s not trying to be a destination pie—its strength is dependable convenience when you keep expectations calibrated.
Must-Try Dishes:
Cheese slice, Pepperoni slice, Garlic knots
What Makes it Special: Pure slice-shop simplicity—fast, affordable, and straightforward.