Skip to main content

Best Mexican Restaurants in Lincoln Square

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
Rosa Mexicano
Broad Mexican menu with reliable taco options

Notable Picks

$$$ Lincoln Square Mexican, Tacos
An Upper West Side mainstay with broad Mexican offerings including well‑spiced tacos alongside fajitas and classic entrées. Its lively dining room and consistent crowd make it suitable for group dinners and celebrations. The tacos here are part of a larger, festive menu rather than a singular focus.
Must-Try Dishes: Carnitas Tacos, Barbacoa Tacos, Guacamole Made Tableside
What makes it special: Broad Mexican menu with reliable taco options

Worthy Picks

$$ Lincoln Square Mexican, Tacos
Mi Ranchito’s food truck offers hearty tacos and Mexican staples around Lincoln Square, often lingering into the later evening for takeaway. Its carnitas and carne asada tacos are praised for generous portions and bold seasonings, providing a satisfying casual option when brick‑and‑mortar spots are winding down. :contentReference[oaicite:2]{index=2}
Must-Try Dishes: Carnitas Tacos, Carne Asada Tacos, Grilled Veggie Tacos
What makes it special: Generous carnitas and carne asada tacos on the go.
$ Lincoln Square Mexican, Tacos
A casual, food truck‑style stop with richly spiced birria tacos that reward adventurous eaters seeking bold flavors on a budget. With concise menu focus and friendly service, this hidden spot punches above its modest footprint. Portions are generous and the birria remains the highlight.
Must-Try Dishes: Birria Tacos, Consommé Dip, Quesabirria
What makes it special: Focused birria tacos with rich, slow‑cooked flavor