Best Comfort Food Classics Pizza Restaurants in Midtown-Times Square

Old-school coal-oven institution near Carnegie Hall turning out char-kissed, thin-crust pies with a crisp snap. It’s dependable for families who want a sit-down Midtown meal with classic Italian sides.

Uncle Paul’s Pizza is a busy corner operation by Grand Central offering by-the-slice pies, full pizzas, wings, pastas, and cold beer. It’s a step up from bare-bones slice counters, with plenty of indoor seating and a menu that works for casual lunches, game-watching, or informal group dinners. Regulars value it for hearty portions, reliable delivery, and broad topping options.

A broad-menu Midtown pizzeria that’s strongest when you treat it as a classic pie-and-slice shop with a few crowd-pleaser styles. The win here is convenience and range—pick one signature slice style, add one square option, and avoid over-ordering from the huge menu.