Best Mexican Restaurants in Midtown-Times Square

A high-velocity counter taqueria that nails Tijuana-style classics with disciplined execution and nonstop turnover that keeps everything fresh. The adobada and carne asada tacos are the clear anchors, with handmade tortillas and clean, punchy salsas. Expect a tight, standing-room vibe and a quick but friendly flow designed for repeat bites, not lingering.

A polished, full-service Mexican spot built for Midtown crowds, with reliably strong tacos and a deep agave program. The menu leans modern but keeps flavors grounded—think well-seasoned steak and shrimp tacos, plus a guac bar that’s actually worth ordering. Best for a longer sit, cocktails, and pre-show pacing rather than a sprint meal.

Amor Loco brings a polished, Theater District-friendly take on Mexican comfort food with strong margarita energy. The menu blends classics with a little NYC flair—nachos, enchiladas, shrimp tacos—served in a colorful, upbeat room. It’s an easy pick for groups who want festive without committing to a full rooftop party.

El Rey Tacos, from the Casa Carmen team, brings Mexico City–style tacos and panuchos to the heart of Times Square with handmade tortillas and focused fillings. It feels like a serious taqueria hiding in a tourist zone, drawing office workers and food-obsessed locals alongside theatergoers.

A modern Mexican cocktail bar‑restaurant mixing tacos and agave‑forward drinks in a mood‑forward setting that fits Midtown nightlife. Good for pre‑show drinks or a casual dinner with friends, with vegetarian and pescatarian options. The ambiance leans more lounge‑bar than casual taqueria, but food remains solid and reasonably priced. :contentReference[oaicite:1]{index=1}

A fast-casual taqueria built for Midtown reliability: efficient ordering, steady portions, and a menu that’s hard to mess up when you’re on a schedule. Best play is a burrito or bowl with a clean protein choice, then keep toppings tight so the flavors don’t blur.

Mexicue’s Midtown outpost turns its barbecue-meets-Mexican concept into a lively Broadway bar for tacos, bowls, and strong margaritas. It’s less about purist regional Mexican and more about fun, shareable plates and happy hour energy a short walk from Bryant Park.