Skip to main content

Best Sweet Treats Escapes Restaurants in Midtown-Times Square

11 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
Legendary New York–style cheesecake that’s deeply tied to Times Square nightlife.

Notable Picks

$$ Midtown-Times Square Bakery
Known city‑wide for creamy, fluffy New York–style cheesecake and a broad menu of diner classics, Junior’s remains a go‑to for late-night dessert and comfort food in Hell’s Kitchen. Its bustling, no-frills setting draws both tourists and longtime locals looking for reliable portions and quality cheesecake slices.
Must-Try Dishes: Original Cheesecake, Strawberry Cheesecake, Carrot Cake Cheesecake
What makes it special: Legendary New York–style cheesecake that’s deeply tied to Times Square nightlife.
$$ Midtown-Times Square Donuts
Upscale Italian‑style pastry shop whose bomboloni and cream‑filled doughnuts stand out among Midtown’s bakery offerings. It draws both tourists and locals looking for a sweet, refined treat near Theatre District theatres. The pistachio‑cream filled doughnut and classic sugar‑dust bombolone are especially popular.
Must-Try Dishes: Pistachio Cream Bombolone, Classic Sugar Bombolone, Chocolate‑filled Doughnut
What makes it special: Italian‑inspired bomboloni with pastry‑house finesse.
$$$ Midtown-Times Square Bakery
An Asian-influenced Italian bakery-café turning out glossy bomboloni, layered pastries, and espresso drinks in a high-energy Times Square setting. It’s more polished and inventive than the average tourist-zone sweet stop, with crowd-pleasers that still show craft.
Must-Try Dishes: Ube Bomboloni, Pistachio Croissant, Tiramisu slice
What makes it special: Italian pastry technique with playful Asian flavor riffs.
$ Midtown-Times Square Bakery
A specialty dessert bakery popular for its airy crèmini puffs, colorful macarons, and seasonal sweet treats — beloved by locals and visitors alike seeking creative pastries near Midtown theaters. The cozy, Instagram‑ready presentation and rotating menu give it a lively, modern‑bakery vibe.
Must-Try Dishes: Crèmini Puff, Macarons, Seasonal Dessert Tart
What makes it special: Crèmini puffs and macarons with creative flavors and presentation near Broadway.

Worthy Picks

$$ Midtown-Times Square Bakery
A Parisian‑style bakery‑café offering crisp croissants, focaccia sandwiches, and Italian‑inspired baked goods — a solid mid‑town option for quick breakfast or pastry and coffee to go. The casual seating and reliable quality make it a consistent choice for commuters or shoppers along Broadway.
Must-Try Dishes: Butter Croissant, Focaccia Sandwich, Pain au Chocolat
What makes it special: European‑style baked goods with reliable consistency in a convenient Midtown location.
$ Midtown-Times Square Bakery
A bright, counter-service sweets shop in the thick of Times Square specializing in cupcakes, cake slices, and custom-style treats. It’s a dependable stop for a quick sugar hit, with vegan and gluten-free options that broaden the appeal.
Must-Try Dishes: Red Velvet Cupcake, NY-style Cheesecake slice, Assorted Cake Pops
What makes it special: Fast, varied cake-and-cupcake case with dietary options.
$ Midtown-Times Square French
A bright French bakery-café steps from Restaurant Row, good for a quick croissant, croque monsieur, or espresso between shows. It doubles as a casual bistro at night with wine, sandwiches, and dessert-forward comfort.
Must-Try Dishes: Butter croissant, Croque monsieur, Crêpe Suzette
What makes it special: A true grab-and-go French bakery that stays open for theater hours.
$$ Midtown-Times Square Bakery
An Italian-style bakery with glossy cornetti and neatly executed tarts, offering a calmer bake-shop feel near Bryant Park/Times Square. Still building its local footprint, but the pastry technique and espresso pairing make it a worthwhile stop.
Must-Try Dishes: Pistachio Cornetto, Lemon Meringue Tart, Focaccia Sandwich
What makes it special: Italian pastry counter with strong cornetti and tart program.
$ Midtown-Times Square Ice Cream
A simple Midtown frozen-yogurt stop that’s strongest when you treat it like a clean, quick cold fix rather than a destination dessert. Stick to one base flavor and one crunchy topping so the texture stays the point, not a sugary pile-on.
Must-Try Dishes: Classic tart froyo, Chocolate froyo, Soft-serve swirl with one topping
What makes it special: Straightforward froyo/soft-serve with a fast, no-drama Midtown setup.
$$$ Midtown-Times Square Sandwiches
A sandwich concept built around melted cheese theatrics—when it hits, it’s a rich, satisfying raclette-style bite that’s more about indulgence than nuance. Treat it like a one-and-done special-occasion lunch: pick a signature cheese-forward build, skip add-on sprawl, and expect it to eat like a full meal.
Must-Try Dishes: Raclette-style cheese sandwich, Swiss Dog, Baked cheese with bread
What makes it special: Cheese-theatrics sandwich shop: raclette energy in Midtown.
7.5
$$ Midtown-Times Square Bakery
A dessert café built around illusion-style, fruit-shaped pastries with French-Asian inspiration—more about visual craft and clean, mousse-forward flavors than big-batch bakery classics. It works best as a single-item stop: choose one signature fruit dessert and keep expectations aligned with novelty and finesse.
Must-Try Dishes: Mango fruit-shaped mousse dessert, Orange fruit-shaped mousse dessert, Pain au chocolat
What makes it special: Fruit-look illusion desserts that prioritize design and mousse finesse.