Best Date Night Magic Greek Restaurants in Park Slope
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Medusa The Greek
A late-night-friendly Greek taverna pairing polished mezze and mains with a lively bar on Fifth Avenue.
Notable Picks
8.8
Medusa The Greek is a modern Park Slope taverna from Mil Gustos Hospitality Group, opened in late 2019, serving elevated takes on classic Greek dishes with an energetic bar scene. Locals use it for everything from late-night gyros and grilled octopus to full dinners before or after Barclays events, helped by long hours and a robust cocktail program.
Must-Try Dishes:
Grilled Octopus, Moussaka, Lamb Chops with Lemon Potatoes
What makes it special: A late-night-friendly Greek taverna pairing polished mezze and mains with a lively bar on Fifth Avenue.
8.7
A long-running, family-owned Greek tavern at 6th Avenue and 14th Street, Athena specializes in generous platters of moussaka, pastitsio, grilled meats, and island-style seafood. Locals lean on it for dependable portions, welcoming service, and lunch and dinner specials that keep it in regular Park Slope rotation.
Must-Try Dishes:
Lamb shank with orzo, Krya Pikilia spread sampler, Spartan Combo platter
What makes it special: Family-run Greek tavern known for hearty classics and generous portions.
#3
Simply Greek
8.3
On busy 5th Avenue, Simply Greek is a newer, polished taverna built around whole grilled fish, mezze, and a full bar, backed by strong delivery and reservation-driven dine-in traffic. Guests come for seafood-focused plates, warm hospitality, and a surprisingly tranquil backyard patio in the middle of Park Slope.
Must-Try Dishes:
Grilled calamari, Whole grilled branzino, Spanakopita
What makes it special: Polished Greek restaurant with a backyard patio and whole-fish focus.