Best Hidden Gems Italian Restaurants in Turtle Bay
7 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Il Tinello
38 years of tradition with owner Benny personally greeting every guest
Notable Picks
#1
Il Tinello
8.6
A 38-year tradition of Northern Italian excellence continues at this East Side outpost. Owner Benny Bello delivers white-glove hospitality with tableside flambéed bananas foster and complimentary grappa, making every guest feel like family.
Must-Try Dishes:
Veal Milanese, Shrimp Scampi Il Tinello, Crab Cappellini
What Makes it Special: 38 years of tradition with owner Benny personally greeting every guest
#2
Il Monello
8.6
Reopened in Turtle Bay after a storied history dating to 1974, this fine dining destination near the UN features Executive Chef Jaime Chabla's refined Italian seafood and steaks. The garden patio and private dining rooms host diplomats and discerning locals alike.
Must-Try Dishes:
Potato-Crusted Sea Bass, Veal Chop Milanese, Chicken Il Monello
What Makes it Special: 50-year legacy reborn with garden dining near the United Nations
#3
Toscana 49
8.5
Sister restaurant to Café Fiorello delivers homemade pasta made daily in-house using traditional Tuscan methods. The intimate white-tablecloth dining room and private upstairs space host devoted regulars who return for poetic recitations of daily specials.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spinach Lasagna, Spaghetti alla Chitarra e Gamberi, Pappa al Pomodoro
What Makes it Special: Daily handmade pasta and servers who describe specials like Italian poetry
8.4
Nestled in the Kimberly Hotel lobby, this modern Italian destination has earned devotion from the gluten-free community with its dedicated allergen-free kitchen. Beyond dietary accommodations, the wood-fired flatbreads and homemade pastas deliver genuine Italian flavors in a cozy, candlelit setting.
Must-Try Dishes:
Butternut Squash Ravioli, Fig and Speck Pizza, Squid Ink Lobster Ravioli
What Makes it Special: Dedicated gluten-free kitchen preparing entire menu safely for celiac guests
8.2
This intimate Turtle Bay wine bar captures the essence of a rustic Italian countryside retreat with exposed brick and chandeliers. The handmade pizzas with bolognese burrata topping and Mike's hot honey have developed a devoted following among neighborhood regulars since 2009.
Must-Try Dishes:
Bolognese Burrata Pizza, Mike's Hot Honey Pizza, Homemade Meatballs
What Makes it Special: Cozy wine bar atmosphere with authentic Italian wines and handmade pizzas since 2009
8.1
Norma’s Turtle Bay location translates the brand’s Sicilian comfort food into a walk-in friendly, high-energy corner spot. Lasagna Palermitana, arancini, and pasta alla Norma come out of a compact kitchen that prioritizes hearty flavors over formality.
Must-Try Dishes:
Lasagna Palermitana, Pasta alla Norma, Arancini catanesi
What Makes it Special: Casual Sicilian counter-service spot where baked pastas and snacks deliver big flavor.
Worthy Picks
This women-owned trattoria offers fresh housemade pasta and curated Italian wines in a cozy upper-level space between 2nd and 3rd Avenues. The intimate setting proves ideal for business lunches and casual date nights, with daily happy hour featuring $12 spritzes drawing neighborhood regulars.
Must-Try Dishes:
Cacio e Pepe, Quattro Formaggi Pasta, Nutella Tiramisu
What Makes it Special: Women-owned neighborhood trattoria with fresh housemade pasta and accessible pricing