Skip to main content

Best American Restaurants in Union Square

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
abc kitchen
Produce-led American dishes in a stylish, market-to-table format.

Notable Picks

$$ Union Square American
Jean-Georges’ Flatiron favorite does vegetable-forward American cooking with a glossy, design-store setting. Plates revolve around peak produce, smart technique, and shareable rhythms, making the meal feel both high-end and approachable. The room’s energy keeps it buzzy without drifting into scene-y.
Must-Try Dishes: Roasted Carrot with avocado & citrus, Pretzel-dusted Calamari, Ricotta Ravioli with herbs & tomato
What makes it special: Produce-led American dishes in a stylish, market-to-table format.
$$ Union Square American
A preserved slice of old New York with stained-glass charm and a sturdy American bar menu. The kitchen focuses on dependable pub classics that pair well with a pint, and the room’s lived-in patina is half the appeal. Great for low-stakes meals that still feel distinctly local.
Must-Try Dishes: Old Town Burger, Shepherd’s Pie, Chicken Pot Pie
What makes it special: Historic bar atmosphere with reliably good American pub fare.

Worthy Picks

$$ Union Square American
A landmark tavern serving straightforward American comfort food in a time-capsule setting. You come as much for the century-old bar-room mood as for the menu of steaks, burgers, and pastas. It’s a dependable neighborhood hang that trades finesse for nostalgia and warmth.
Must-Try Dishes: Steak Frites, Classic Cheeseburger, Pot Roast
What makes it special: One of NYC’s oldest taverns with an unbeatable historic vibe.