Best Girls Night Out Approved Restaurants in Upper East Side-Yorkville
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Flex Mussels
Mussel pots plus fries that double as broth sponges.
Notable Picks
#1
Flex Mussels
8.3
A Lenox Hill seafood room built around mussel pots and oysters, where hand-cut fries work best as a salty side to soak up broths and wine. The fries aren’t the whole story here, but they’re a smart supporting order that rounds out a shareable, date-friendly meal.
Must-Try Dishes:
Hand cut fries, Mussels (choose one signature preparation), Oysters
What makes it special: Mussel pots plus fries that double as broth sponges.
#2
Flex Mussels
8.3
Flex Mussels is a relaxed Upper East Side staple known for hearty mussels steamed in flavorful broths and locally beloved happy hour deals. The inviting space and reliable execution keep both locals and visitors returning. Service is friendly, and the menu offers accessible seafood favorites.
Must-Try Dishes:
Classic White Wine Mussels, Parma Mussels, Oysters on the Half Shell
What makes it special: Generous pots of mussels with varied broths and great happy hour energy.
#3
Libbi
8
A newer Upper East Side kosher dairy Mediterranean spot from the Abaita team, designed for a polished sit-down meal with a menu that swings from brunch-forward plates to more chef-y mains. The smart order is one signature sweet/savory anchor and one shareable mid-plate so it feels intentional, not like you’re sampling at random.
Must-Try Dishes:
Pancakes with figs and orange marmalade, Spicy tomato pizza with shiitakes, Cheesy pasta gratin
What makes it special: Abaita team’s polished kosher dairy Mediterranean with a brunch-to-dinner swing.