Skip to main content

Best Middle Eastern Restaurants in Upper West Side (Central)

9 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
Dagon
Levantine-leaning Israeli cooking with house breads and mezze worth planning around.

Notable Picks

8.8
$ Upper West Side (Central) Mediterranean, Middle Eastern
Modern Israeli restaurant on a prominent Broadway corner serving mezze, breads, and wood-leaning mains with Levantine flavors. Locals use it for date nights, celebrations, and nights when they want serious cooking and a buzzier room than most of the neighborhood.
Must-Try Dishes: Kubaneh, Crispy Roasted Lamb, Shishbarak
What makes it special: Levantine-leaning Israeli cooking with house breads and mezze worth planning around.
$$ Upper West Side (Central) Middle Eastern
A beloved Upper West Side Middle Eastern spot known for generously portioned, fresh hummus and falafel with lively, welcoming service. Locals love it for casual lunches and family dinners where quality meets value.
Must-Try Dishes: Classic Hummus Platter, Falafel Wrap, Grilled Chicken Shawarma
What makes it special: Consistently fresh, hearty hummus and falafel with generous portions
$ Upper West Side (Central) Mediterranean, Greek
Casual Mediterranean restaurant on Columbus serving mixed grills, salads, and platters in a bright, flexible dining room. It’s a reliable option when you want straightforward kebabs, dips, and a few healthier-leaning plates without committing to a long meal.
Must-Try Dishes: Mixed Grill Platter, Chicken Shawarma Plate, Kunafa
What makes it special: Flexible neighborhood spot balancing grilled platters, salads, and shareable mezze.
$$ Upper West Side (Central) Middle Eastern, Brunch
Miriam serves Mediterranean and Middle Eastern-inspired dishes with a focus on casual comfort and seasonal ingredients. Brunch and dinner both deliver satisfying plates in a relaxed setting.
Must-Try Dishes: Lamb Shawarma Bowl, Hummus with Lamb, Date and Walnut Cake
What makes it special: Mediterranean-Middle Eastern fusion with seasonal touches
$$ Upper West Side (Central) Mediterranean, Middle Eastern
Compact Druze-Israeli restaurant known for oversized laffa-style bread, burekas, and mezze-heavy platters. Locals treat it as a cozy alternative to larger spots when they want homestyle Middle Eastern flavors and big portions in a low-key setting.
Must-Try Dishes: Gazala's Platter, Spinach Burekas, Hummus with Sujuk
What makes it special: Druze-run kitchen turning out laffa breads, burekas, and mezze with generous portions.

Worthy Picks

$ Upper West Side (Central) Mediterranean, Middle Eastern
A no-frills shawarma counter that prioritizes flavor and speed—big platters, punchy toppings, and a build-your-own energy that works best for takeout. It lands when you choose one protein, go heavy on the salads/pickles, and treat it like a satisfying, direct-hit meal.
Must-Try Dishes: Chicken shawarma platter, Shawarma in laffa, Falafel pita
What makes it special: Big, topping-forward shawarma that’s built for maximum satisfaction fast.
$$ Upper West Side (Central) Middle Eastern
A newer Yemeni café (established 2024) that brings Middle Eastern coffee culture to the Upper West Side with spiced drinks, sweets, and a sit-and-sip rhythm. Come for one signature latte or tea plus one pastry or cake—treat it like a focused coffee-and-dessert stop, not a full meal destination.
Must-Try Dishes: Yemeni coffee drink, Pistachio latte, Saffron milk cake
What makes it special: A Yemeni coffee-and-sweets café that feels built for lingering.
$ Upper West Side (Central) Mediterranean, Middle Eastern
Compact branch of a long-running New York falafel mini-chain serving sandwiches, platters, and late-night snacks. It’s a practical choice for quick, inexpensive Middle Eastern food when you want to eat at the counter, grab-and-go, or sit briefly by the windows.
Must-Try Dishes: Falafel Sandwich, Chicken Shawarma Sandwich, Baklava
What makes it special: Classic New York falafel counter delivering fast, inexpensive sandwiches and platters.
7.7
$$ Upper West Side (Central) Middle Eastern
Fast-casual Middle Eastern spot specializing in build-your-own bowls, salads, and pitas with shawarma, falafel, and grilled proteins. Upper West Siders lean on it for customizable lunches and early dinners that feel fresher than typical grab-and-go.
Must-Try Dishes: Chicken shawarma bowl, Falafel pita with hummus, Cauliflower shawarma bowl
What makes it special: Counter-service Middle Eastern bowls with lots of customization and veg options.