Skip to main content

Best Mexican Restaurants in Upper West Side-Lincoln Square

6 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: February 2026

Our Top Pick
The Burrito Bar
Endless burrito customization options.

Notable Picks

$$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square Mexican, Burritos
This trendy spot focuses on customization, offering a wide variety of toppings and burrito styles for the discerning eater.
Must-Try Dishes: Custom Burrito, Chipotle Chicken Burrito, Veggie Burrito
What makes it special: Endless burrito customization options.
$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square Mexican, Burritos
A cozy spot for budget-friendly burritos with all the traditional fillings and flavors.
Must-Try Dishes: Classic Beef Burrito, Chicken Burrito, Fish Tacos
What makes it special: Affordable, no-frills burritos with satisfying portions.
$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square Mexican
A food truck serving hearty tacos and Mexican staples around Lincoln Square.
Must-Try Dishes: Carnitas Taco, Carne Asada Taco, Veggie Tacos
What makes it special: Generous portions of tacos with flavorful meats and fillings.
$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square Mexican
A casual counter spot serving classic street tacos with hearty fillings.
Must-Try Dishes: Carne Asada Taco, Al Pastor Taco, Quesadilla
What makes it special: Affordable street tacos with authentic flavors.
$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square Mexican, Tacos
Birria‑Landia’s taco truck serves juicy birria tacos on Broadway into the late evening, drawing a dedicated local following for its slow‑simmered beef and consommé. Though modest in size and review count, its tacos stand out for deep flavors and after‑hours accessibility. Nights often see a steady stream of late diners seeking rich birria and hand‑made tortillas. :contentReference[oaicite:0]{index=0}
Must-Try Dishes: Beef Birria Tacos, Birria Quesabirria, Consommé Dip
What makes it special: Slow‑simmered birria tacos with rich consommé.

Worthy Picks

$ Upper West Side-Lincoln Square Mexican, Tacos
Tacos y Quesadillas Mexico is a cash‑friendly counter spot dishing up classic street tacos and quesadillas with straightforward, well‑seasoned fillings. It’s a neighborhood favorite for quick bites early in the evening, though its shorter hours limit true late night runs. Still, its authentic flavors and budget pricing make it a go‑to for casual taco cravings. :contentReference[oaicite:1]{index=1}
Must-Try Dishes: Carne Asada Tacos, Al Pastor Tacos, Cheese Quesadilla
What makes it special: Classic street‑style tacos at budget prices.