Best Pizza Restaurants in Upper West Side-Lincoln Square
2 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Made in New York Pizza
Classic NY slice with crispy square and foldable crust
Notable Picks
8.5
A reliable slice joint on the Upper West Side serving classic New York‑style pizza with a crispy, foldable crust and late‑night hours on weekends that satisfy late cravings.
Must-Try Dishes:
Spicy Pepperoni Square, Margherita Slice, White Slice
What makes it special: Classic NY slice with crispy square and foldable crust
Eclectic New Orleans‑inspired pizza with creative toppings and an upbeat vibe, staying open late on weekend nights for a slice after drinks or performances nearby.
Must-Try Dishes:
Bayou Beast, Green Lantern, Vegan Cajun
What makes it special: Cajun‑inspired, colorful pizza creativity