Best Late Night Restaurants in Westchester Square
3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked
Last Updated: February 2026
Our Top Pick
Estrellita Poblana IV
High-volume Puebla-style spot where mole plates and mixed grills anchor big family meals.
Notable Picks
8.3
Estrellita Poblana IV is a busy Westchester Square staple for classic Puebla-style Mexican, drawing steady crowds for mole plates, tacos, and mixed grills. With well over a thousand Google and Yelp reviews and late hours most nights, it functions as the default sit-down Mexican choice for much of 10461.
Must-Try Dishes:
Mole Poblano, Tacos al Pastor, Parrillada Mixta
What Makes it Special: High-volume Puebla-style spot where mole plates and mixed grills anchor big family meals.
Worthy Picks
7.9
Fogon Restaurant doubles as a Latin American dining room and nightlife hub, serving hefty mofongos and grilled steaks before the lights dim for DJ-driven evenings that stretch past midnight. It’s one of the neighborhood’s most energetic spots when you want dinner that easily rolls into a night out.
Must-Try Dishes:
Grilled Skirt Steak / Churrasco al Fogon, Lobster Mofongo, Fogon Style Fried Rice
What Makes it Special: Latin spot where mofongos, steaks, and DJs turn dinner into nightlife.
5 Star Pizza Pasta & Burgers II is a Westchester Avenue pizzeria that also runs a full burger board, making it a reliable late-night option for patties, fries, and pies in one place. Most orders are takeout or delivery, and portions lean large for the price.
Must-Try Dishes:
Plain 5 Stars Burger, Deluxe 5 Stars Burger, Plain Impossible Burger
What Makes it Special: Pizza shop with an unexpectedly deep burger lineup for late nights.