30 Photos
ZipPicks Awards
Best Pizza in Culver City
Master Critic Review
Petramale Pizza
7.9
A cash-only pop-up operating out of Venice Church's parking lot, turning out traditional New York-style pies from a setup that prioritizes crust and char over ambiance. The stripped-down format keeps things moving fast for Westside locals who want legit East Coast slices without the fuss.
Must-Try Dishes:
New York Style Pies, Meatball, Cannolis
Scores:
Value: 8
Service: 7.5
Consistency: 8.3
Food Quality: 8.3
Atmosphere: 7.5
Cultural Relevance: 7.5
What makes it special: Old-school New York style pizza baked in traditional ovens, cash-only operation that keeps it authentic
Who should go: Pizza purists craving East Coast slices on the Westside
When to visit: Early dinner to snag outdoor seating before crowds
What to order: Start with a meatball, split a whole pie, finish with cannolis
Insider tip: Bring cash—they don't take cards
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Church parking lot on-site—the pop-up operates directly from the lot at Venice Church, so parking is straightforward
Dress code: Bare-bones casual—outdoor church parking lot setting with picnic tables, no dress code expectations
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Cheese pizzas available (Margherita, Sicilian)—no vegan cheese offered; they discontinued vegan products due to low demand
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Only for a very casual, low-key date. This is a parking lot pizza pop-up with picnic tables, a pizza trailer, and stacks of boxes - not a traditional restaurant. Great for a fun, adventurous date where you bond over incredible NY-style pizza in an informal setting. Not suitable if you're looking for romantic ambiance, intimate conversation, or anywhere to dress up.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes - no reservations taken or needed. This is a casual Friday-only pop-up (roughly 12pm-7pm) operating on a walk-up and call-ahead basis. Call ahead at (310) 619-7740 if you want your pizza ready when you arrive. Expect a wait during peak hours as pies are made to order. Bring cash - cards not accepted.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes - the casual outdoor parking lot setting is very forgiving for families. Kids can move around freely, noise isn't an issue, and pizza by the slice keeps everyone happy. No formal kids menu or high chairs since this is a pop-up, not a restaurant. The relaxed vibe makes it easy for parents. Best to arrive earlier in the afternoon with young children.
Is it good for groups? Yes - this is ideal for groups. Whole pies ($30+) feed 3-4 people, picnic tables accommodate casual group dining, and the outdoor parking lot setting handles larger parties easily. Locals regularly pick up multiple pies for gatherings. Call ahead for large orders to ensure your pizzas are ready. No private rooms or formal group bookings - just show up with your crew.
Is there outdoor seating? Yes - all seating is outdoors. This pop-up operates in a church parking lot with picnic tables for on-site dining. No indoor option exists. The setting is casual and exposed to weather, so check conditions before visiting. Most customers grab pies to-go, but eating on-site with friends at the picnic tables is part of the experience.
Best For
Better for: Westside locals picking up whole pies for a party, groups of friends sharing slices at picnic tables, or anyone with nostalgia for authentic NY-style thin crust
Skip if: You're particular about pizza sauce (some find it too cooked-down), don't have cash (cards not accepted), or need service outside Friday afternoons
Hours
MondayClosed
TuesdayClosed
WednesdayClosed
ThursdayClosed
Friday12pm - 7pm
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed