1 Photo
ZipPicks Awards
Best Bakery in Palms-Cheviot Hills
Master Critic Review
Pickle & Pie
7.5
A women-owned Palms bakery built around Southern-style sweet potato pies, biscuit sandwiches, and hand pies that rotate with the seasons. The small-batch, seasonal-menu format rewards repeat visits, though the operation is new enough that the track record is still being written. Expect a tiny counter-service space where the focus is entirely on what comes out of the oven.
Must-Try Dishes:
Seasonal Sweet Potato Pie, Buttermilk Biscuit Sandwiches, House-Made Jam Hand Pies
Scores:
Value: 7.5
Service: 7.5
Consistency: 7.5
Food Quality: 7.8
Atmosphere: 7.3
Cultural Relevance: 7
What makes it special: Tiny, women-owned Palms bakery turning out Southern-style pies and savory-sweet bakes on a rotating seasonal menu
Who should go: Baked-goods devotees who love seasonal, small-batch finds
When to visit: Afternoons for the freshest hand-pie runs
What to order: Grab a sweet potato pie slice, a biscuit sandwich for savory balance, and a hand pie for the road
Insider tip: The menu rotates frequently — check their social pages before visiting so you don't miss a seasonal favorite
Logistics & Planning
Dietary Options
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Not a traditional date spot — this is a tiny counter-service bakery, not a sit-down restaurant. That said, it could work as a charming, low-pressure stop on a date: grab hand pies and sweet potato pie to share on a walk. The homey, personal vibe and rotating seasonal menu give you something to talk about. Best as part of a multi-stop date rather than the main event.
Can I get a table without a reservation? No reservations needed — this is a walk-in, counter-service bakery. However, items sell out since everything is small-batch and the menu rotates. For the best selection, visit in the afternoon when fresh hand-pie runs come out. Preorders are available through their Instagram (@pickleandpiela) if you want to guarantee specific items.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes — it's a casual bakery selling pies, hand pies, and sweet baked goods, which are naturally kid-appealing. The low-key, homey atmosphere means no one will stress about a noisy toddler. No formal kids menu (it's a bakery, not a restaurant), but the hand pies and jam-filled treats are easy for small hands. Quick in-and-out service keeps things simple with little ones.
Is it good for groups? Not ideal — this is a tiny storefront bakery, not a sit-down dining space. A group of 2-3 grabbing pies to go works fine, but there's no large table or dining area for a group gathering. For a group outing, consider ordering a preorder batch of pies through their Instagram and enjoying them at a nearby park or gathering spot instead.
Is there outdoor seating? No confirmed outdoor seating. Pickle & Pie operates out of a small suite in the Palms Point complex and functions primarily as a counter-service and takeout bakery. Not specified online whether any bench or patio seating exists outside the suite — call (424) 543-4354 to confirm if any grab-and-sit options are available on-site.
Best For
Better for: Afternoon sweet-tooth runs and grab-and-go hand pies — a tiny, women-owned bakery with rotating Southern-style seasonal treats that rewards repeat visits over one-time stops
Consider Alternatives If: You want a full sit-down meal or dinner service — this is a small-batch bakery with limited hours and a rotating menu, not a restaurant