0 Followers
Pickler Sandwich Shop
Master Critic Review
Pickler Sandwich Shop
7.8
Vibes:
Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance
Comfort Food Classics
Quick Bites Champions
Solo Dining Sanctuaries
On East 45th between 2nd and 3rd, Pickler is a compact counter-service shop focused on hefty deli-style sandwiches with better bread and sharper toppings than most Midtown chains. Regulars praise the Reuben, turkey club and pickle-forward twists that make it a reliable, slightly indulgent lunch stop.
Must-Try Dishes:
Turkey Club Sandwich, Rachel Sandwich, Avo Grilled Cheese
Scores:
Value: 8.1
Service: 7.8
Consistency: 8.1
Food Quality: 8.4
Atmosphere: 6.2
Cultural Relevance: 7.6
What makes it special: Tight Midtown deli turning out stacked classics with standout pickles and pressed sandwiches.
Who should go: Sandwich traditionalists craving Reubens, clubs and melty grills.
When to visit: Slightly before noon or after one for shorter lines.
What to order: Turkey Club, Rachel Sandwich, Avo Grilled Cheese.
Insider tip: Portions are big; split a sandwich and add fries if budgeting.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking on 45th Street is limited and turnover is high; rely on nearby garages along 2nd or 3rd Avenue if driving.
Dress code: Casual — office attire, jeans and hoodies all fit the norm for a quick Midtown sandwich stop.
Noise level: Moderate; counter chatter and takeout traffic but still easy to hold a conversation.
Weekend wait: Not applicable — primarily a weekday lunch destination with reduced weekend hours.
Weekday lunch: 5–10 minutes during peak corporate lunch rush; often no wait slightly before noon or after 1:15pm.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Several options including grilled cheese builds and customizable veggie-forward sandwiches.
Vegan options: Limited — some sandwiches can be modified by removing dairy, but no dedicated vegan builds.
Gluten-free options: Gluten-free bread is not guaranteed; safe options are limited to salad-style builds if offered.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Not ideal — it’s counter-service, compact and fast-moving, better for solo or coworker lunches than leisurely dates.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes — no reservations needed. Seating is limited, but turnover is quick, and most guests take food to go.
Is it kid-friendly? Generally yes for older kids who enjoy deli-style sandwiches; no high chairs or space for strollers, so not ideal for toddlers.
Best For
Better for: Hefty classic deli sandwiches with sharper toppings and pickle-focused twists that outclass most chain delis nearby.
Skip if: You want a relaxed sit-down meal, vegan options, or ample seating — nearby cafés and larger delis may suit those needs better.