Best Hidden Gems Burgers Restaurants in New York

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: April 2026

Our Top Pick

CakeBurgers

Burgers, custom cakes & handmade milkshakes in a nostalgic 1950s-themed spot with a working jukebox.

Essential Picks

#1 CakeBurgers

9.5

$$ Bakery, Sandwiches Manhattan

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Family Friendly Favorites Outdoor Dining Oasis Sports Bar Central

Burgers, custom cakes & handmade milkshakes in a nostalgic 1950s-themed spot with a working jukebox.

Highlights: Dine In, Outdoor Seating, Delivery, Takeout

#2 Stash Burger

9.4

Burgers, Chicken Manhattan

Vibes: Hidden Gems Heaven

Highlights: Dine In, Delivery, Takeout

#3 HOLY BUNZ

9.1

$$ Burgers, Halal Marine Park

Vibes: Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries Hidden Gems Heaven

Highlights: Dine In, Delivery, Takeout, Reservations