0 Followers
Sagaponack
Master Critic Review
Sagaponack
8.3
A Flatiron seafood bar that’s best when you treat it like an oyster-and-cocktails mission with a few smart plates to round it out. The energy leans social, and the menu’s sweet spot is fresh raw-bar starters plus one seafood-forward main that doesn’t overcomplicate the moment.
Must-Try Dishes:
$1 oysters (happy hour), lobster roll, fluke tartare
Scores:
Value: 8.4
Service: 7.9
Consistency: 8.1
Food Quality: 8.6
Atmosphere: 7.2
Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: A seafood-bar playbook built around oysters, cocktails, and fast-hitting plates.
Who should go: Oyster fans and after-work drink crews
When to visit: Happy hour weekdays or early Saturday
What to order: Oysters, fluke tartare, lobster roll
Insider tip: Use happy hour for oysters, then order one main to finish.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking is limited and competitive; nearby paid garages are the most reliable option, especially after 6pm.
Dress code: Smart casual. Jeans are fine, but most guests lean polished—date-night or after-work chic fits the room.
Noise level: Moderate to lively. Easy conversation earlier in the evening; gets louder during peak happy hour.
Weekend wait: 30–45 minutes without a reservation, especially during prime time
Weekday lunch: Typically no wait or very short wait
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Limited but workable—salads, sides, and a few non-seafood starters
Vegan options: Very limited—best approached as drinks plus a light snack
Gluten-free options: Several naturally gluten-free raw bar and seafood options; staff can guide you
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Yes—especially for cocktails and oysters. The energy is social but not chaotic, and sharing a few plates keeps things low-pressure.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Often yes, particularly during happy hour or earlier in the evening. Peak weekend dinner hours can mean a short wait.
Is it kid-friendly? Not really. This is an adult-leaning seafood bar with a cocktail-forward vibe—better for dates or groups than families.
Best For
Better for: Oysters, cocktails, and a buzzy Flatiron scene that works equally well for happy hour or a casual date night.
Skip if: You want a quiet, formal seafood dinner or need extensive non-seafood or vegan options.