0 Followers
Shelsky's of Brooklyn Appetizing & Delicatessen
Master Critic Review
Shelsky's of Brooklyn Appetizing & Delicatessen
8.7
Shelsky's of Brooklyn is a modern Jewish appetizing shop where hand-rolled bagels become the base for smoked fish, caviar, and composed sandwiches rather than quick grab-and-go snacks. Regulars treat it as a destination for luxe bagel-and-lox builds, whitefish salad, and creative combinations built on in-house cured fish and robust cream cheeses. Prices are higher than a typical bagel counter, but the ingredient quality and depth of flavor justify making it a special weekend stop.
Must-Try Dishes:
Brooklyn Native bagel sandwich with smoked fish, Everything bagel with nova and scallion cream cheese, Bialy or bagel with whitefish salad
Scores:
Value: 7.6
Service: 8.4
Consistency: 8.8
Food Quality: 9.2
Atmosphere: 7.1
Cultural Relevance: 9
What makes it special: Bagels pair with serious smoked fish and composed appetizing plates rather than simple deli spreads.
Who should go: Bagel-and-lox obsessives willing to pay for top-tier fish.
When to visit: Weekend mornings and early afternoons for peak appetizing selection.
What to order: Brooklyn Native sandwich, everything with nova and scallion, whitefish salad on a bagel.
Insider tip: Plan to take sandwiches and smoked fish to-go; lines move faster if you study the menu before stepping up to order.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Street parking on Court and Smith Streets is limited, especially on weekends; expect to circle or use nearby paid garages within a 5–7 minute walk.
Dress code: Casual; most guests come in weekend attire like jeans, sweaters, and jackets. No need to dress up unless you're making it part of a special brunch outing.
Noise level: Moderate; the shop is lively but not overwhelming, with enough quiet to hold a normal conversation while ordering or waiting.
Weekend wait: Not applicable; Shelsky’s is primarily a daytime appetizing and bagel destination and closes before dinner hours.
Weekday lunch: Short to moderate waits; typically 5–15 minutes depending on smoked fish demand and pre-orders.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes — several sandwiches and spreads can be made vegetarian, including egg salads, cream cheeses, and veggie-forward combinations.
Vegan options: Limited — bagels are vegan but fillings are mostly dairy or fish; vegan customers may stick to plain bagels with veggie toppings.
Gluten-free options: Moderate — gluten-free bagels are not guaranteed, and cross-contact is possible due to the appetizing format; best to call ahead.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Yes for a casual morning or mid-day date focused on great food rather than ambiance. It’s more of a grab-and-go or quick counter-service stop than a sit-down setting, so choose it if shared food enthusiasm is the vibe.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes — Shelsky’s operates without reservations, but seating is minimal. Expect to take your food to-go or enjoy it nearby unless you arrive early.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes for most ages; counter service is fast, and kids who enjoy bagels or simple spreads will be fine. Limited seating means stroller navigation may be tight during peak hours.
Best For
Better for: High-end smoked fish, curated appetizing builds, and premium bagel-and-lox experiences that outclass standard bagel counters.
Skip if: You want cheap, quick bagels; or you need spacious seating for lingering meals — traditional bagel shops or diners may be better fits.