0 Followers
Smithereens
Master Critic Review
Smithereens
8.5
A dim, subterranean seafood-centric spot where private events feel like a focused chef’s dinner in a tight, atmospheric room. It’s strongest for groups who want a structured menu and serious cooking rather than a flexible, mix-and-match party format.
Must-Try Dishes:
Amberjack belly, Boston mackerel, Beans with shrimp and uni
Scores:
Value: 7
Service: 8.2
Consistency: 8.5
Food Quality: 9
Atmosphere: 8.6
Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: A private-event format that pairs a tight room with serious seafood cooking.
Who should go: Food-first groups and special-occasion dinners
When to visit: Midweek for the calmest service flow
What to order: Amberjack, mackerel, beans with seafood
Insider tip: Treat it like a coursed menu—don’t try to DIY an à la carte feast.
Logistics & Planning
Parking: No valet. Street parking is very limited in the East Village and especially difficult after 6pm—plan on rideshare or walking from nearby avenues.
Dress code: Dressy smart casual to upscale—jackets, dark denim, and elevated evening wear fit the room; sneakers and ultra-casual looks feel out of place.
Noise level: Low to moderate—intimate and controlled, built for focused conversation rather than buzz.
Weekend wait: Reservation-only for most nights; walk-ins are unlikely, especially for private dining.
Weekday lunch: Not applicable—primarily an evening-focused operation.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Limited—some vegetable-driven courses are available, but the menu is seafood-forward and best suited to pescatarians.
Vegan options: Very limited—possible with advance notice, but not the kitchen’s strength.
Gluten-free options: Yes—many seafood preparations are naturally gluten-free, and the kitchen can accommodate with notice.
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Better for established dates than first ones—the intimate, dim room and structured menu shine when you’re already comfortable lingering and committing to a longer meal.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Unlikely. This is a reservation-driven spot, and private dining requires advance planning—book ahead to avoid disappointment.
Is it kid-friendly? No—this is an adult, fine-dining environment with pacing and flavors designed for focused, grown-up meals.
Best For
Better for: Intimate, chef-led private dinners where seafood quality, pacing, and atmosphere matter more than menu flexibility or crowd energy.
Skip if: You want a loud celebration, flexible à la carte ordering, or broad dietary accommodation—look to larger, more adaptable private dining rooms instead.