30 Photos
ZipPicks Awards
Best Bakery in Brentwood
Master Critic Review
SusieCakes (Brentwood)
7.8
A from-scratch American bakery that builds everything with real butter and no mixes—the red velvet cake and frosting-topped cookies draw repeat customers who grew up with similar family recipes. The counter-service format works for quick birthday pickups and nostalgic treat runs in Brentwood, though street parking on San Vicente requires patience.
Must-Try Dishes:
Cupcakes, Red Velvet Cake, Frosting-Topped Cookies
Scores:
Value: 7.5
Service: 7.5
Consistency: 8
Food Quality: 8
Atmosphere: 7.5
Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: Nostalgic from-scratch American bakery using real butter, no mixes, and recipes inspired by family traditions
Who should go: Birthday planners and anyone craving nostalgic homemade desserts
When to visit: Weekday mornings for full selection before popular items sell out
What to order: Grab a cupcake for now, a slice of red velvet for later, and extra frosting on everything
Insider tip: Ask about seasonal flavors—they rotate limited-time cupcakes and cakes monthly
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Metered street parking on San Vicente Blvd—expect difficulty finding spots in this busy area
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Most baked goods are vegetarian (contain eggs and dairy)
Vegan options: No vegan options available
Gluten-free options: Limited options: flourless peanut butter cookie, flourless chocolate cupcakes, vanilla pudding, Susie's Vanilla Cake (made without gluten)
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Not as a destination, but works as a sweet add-on. This is a bakery counter with minimal seating, not a sit-down restaurant. Better suited for picking up cupcakes or cake slices to enjoy during a walk along San Vicente or as a surprise dessert to bring to your actual date spot. The nostalgic, cheerful atmosphere is charming for a quick 15-minute treat stop, but there's no intimate seating for extended conversation.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Yes - no reservations needed or accepted. This is a walk-in bakery counter. Lines are typically short (unlike some LA bakeries with long waits), though the shop stays busy. For custom cakes or specialty items, 24-48 hours advance notice is required for ordering, but for counter treats like cupcakes, cookies, and cake slices, just walk in during their 10am-7pm daily hours.
Is it kid-friendly? Yes - this is essentially a candy store for the cake-loving crowd. Kids love the colorful cupcake display case and cookie selection. They offer themed birthday cakes (Dinosaur, Unicorn, Minecraft, Barbie), smash cakes for first birthdays, and DIY cupcake decorating kits for family activities. Casual, quick-service environment means kids can pop in, pick a treat, and go without any fuss about behavior.
Is it good for groups? No for dining in - limited seating makes this unsuitable for groups wanting to sit together. Yes for ordering party desserts - they're specialists in celebration cakes serving 20-30 people, cupcake platters, and cookie boxes. For office parties, birthdays, or events, order ahead (24-48 hours notice required). For a group wanting to eat together on-site, look elsewhere.
Is there outdoor seating? No dedicated outdoor seating confirmed at this location. This is primarily a grab-and-go bakery. Some visitors mention enjoying treats on nearby benches along San Vicente Blvd, but the bakery itself does not have a patio. Street parking is limited and metered.
Best For
Better for: Quick grab-and-go desserts, birthday cakes, custom celebration cakes with 24hr notice—no long lines typical of other cupcake shops
Consider Alternatives If: You need vegan or dairy-free desserts, or if you can't find parking
Hours
Monday10am - 7pm
Tuesday10am - 7pm
Wednesday10am - 7pm
Thursday10am - 7pm
Friday10am - 7pm
Saturday10am - 7pm
Sunday10am - 7pm