0 Followers
Vito's Pizza
Master Critic Review
Vito's Pizza
8.1
East Coast-style pizzeria serving thin-crust New York pies with crispy char and proper fold. The family-owned spot draws locals for its coal-oven taste and communal bench seating.
Must-Try Dishes:
Classic Cheese Slice, Pesto White Pizza, Pepperoni Pie
Scores:
Value: 8.3
Service: 7.9
Consistency: 8.4
Food Quality: 8.2
Atmosphere: 7.6
Cultural Relevance: 8
What makes it special: Authentic New Jersey-style pizza with that distinctive East Coast thin crust
Who should go: NY pizza purists and late-night slice seekers
When to visit: Lunch for quick slices, evenings for full pies
What to order: Classic cheese slice, pesto white pizza, meatball sub
Insider tip: Parking lot in back has limited spots—arrive early or use CVS nearby
Logistics & Planning
Parking: Small lot behind restaurant with 8-10 spots, fills up quickly during peak hours. CVS parking next door works as backup. Street parking on Olympic Blvd is metered until 8pm.
Dress code: Casual all the way - jeans, t-shirts, athletic wear all normal. This is a come-as-you-are neighborhood spot.
Noise level: Lively but manageable - communal seating creates buzz, but you can still have a conversation without raising your voice.
Weekend wait: 15-25 min for counter seats during peak (7-9pm), grab-and-go slices usually under 10 minutes
Weekday lunch: 5-10 min max, mostly just ordering time. Lunch rush moves fast.
Dietary Options
Vegetarian options: Yes - cheese pizza, veggie slices, pesto white pizza, and eggplant parm sub all solid options
Vegan options: Limited - can do marinara pizza without cheese, but this is a dairy-forward spot
Gluten-free options: No - traditional coal-oven pizzeria focused on classic thin crust, no GF options available
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Better for casual 2nd or 3rd dates. Communal bench seating and sports TV create fun, low-pressure vibes, but not intimate. Great if you both love pizza and want something relaxed.
Can I get a table without a reservation? They don't take reservations - it's walk-in only with communal seating. Weekday lunches and off-peak hours (3-5pm) are your best bet for minimal wait. Weekend evenings expect 15-20 minutes.
Is it kid-friendly? Extremely - families are regulars here. Kids love the pizza-by-the-slice format, casual vibe, and there's usually a game on TV. No kids menu needed since slices are perfect portions for little ones.
Best For
Better for: Best authentic East Coast thin-crust pizza in Midtown - beats chains on taste, beats upscale spots on price and speed. Perfect for late-night cravings (open until midnight) and quick lunch grabs.
Skip if: You want: upscale date-night ambiance, gluten-free options, Detroit/Chicago-style thick crust, or quiet conversation space. Also skip if you need reservations or valet parking.