ZipPicks Awards
Best Restaurants With Private Dining Rooms in East Village
Master Critic Review
Whiskey Cellar NYC
7.7
A nightlife-leaning East Village cocktail bar that doubles as a surprisingly practical private dining venue in its back rooms. The food is simple but solid—think burgers and bar bites—while the value and privacy make it a “hidden” option for casual parties.
Must-Try Dishes:
House burger, Pastry puffs with caviar, Seasonal craft cocktails
Scores:
Value: 8.6
Service: 7.7
Consistency: 7.2
Food Quality: 7.5
Atmosphere: 7.9
Cultural Relevance: 6.6
What makes it special: A fully private back-room bar with food and no-frills booking.
Who should go: Budget-minded groups who want privacy and drinks.
When to visit: Early evening to lock in seating.
What to order: Burger, pastry puffs, a round of house cocktails.
Insider tip: Bring your own playlist—rooms are set up for it.
Logistics & Planning
Noise level: Intimate speakeasy setting with dim lighting and plush seating—conducive to conversation
Dietary Options
Good to Know
Is this good for a first date? Yes - this speakeasy-style underground bar has dim lighting, plush seating, and exposed brick arches that create an intimate, romantic atmosphere. The cozy downstairs cellar area with its own bar is especially conducive to conversation. Reviewers specifically note it's great for a "chill romantic date night." Request a spot in the cellar for extra privacy.
Can I get a table without a reservation? Walk-ins may be possible on weeknights, but availability is uncertain since the venue heavily focuses on private events and bookings. Weekends often have minimum-spend private reservations locked in. Your best bet is calling after 5pm at 917-214-0589 to check same-day availability. For groups or weekend visits, book in advance.
Is it kid-friendly? No - this is an adults-only cocktail bar and event space. The venue operates exclusively during evening hours (opens 4-5pm), has no kids menu or food service (outside catering only for private events), and the speakeasy atmosphere with whiskey-focused drinks is designed for adult gatherings.
Is it good for groups? Yes - this is the venue's specialty. The Back Room accommodates up to 35 guests; the main Whiskey Cellar space fits up to 50. Private bookings include your own bartender and bar. Weekend minimums: $600-$800 for early sessions (5pm-9pm), $1,400-$1,900 for late sessions (9pm-2am). Weekday 5-hour sessions start at $500. Book at least 1-2 weeks ahead for weekend dates.
Is there outdoor seating? No - this is a below-ground speakeasy-style cellar bar with no outdoor seating. The appeal is the cozy, intimate underground atmosphere.
Best For
Better for: Private celebrations, date nights, and group gatherings where you want to actually talk—intimate underground space with craft cocktails fits the assigned vibes perfectly
Consider Alternatives If: You're looking for dinner—this is a cocktail bar and event space, not a restaurant (BYO catering for events)
Hours
MondayClosed
Tuesday5pm - 12am
Wednesday5pm - 12am
Thursday5pm - 12am
Friday5pm - 2am
Saturday5pm - 2am
Sunday4pm - 12am