What is the best American restaurant in Chelsea?

Family Meal at Blue Hill is our top pick for American restaurants in Chelsea, scoring 9.0/10. Refined farm-to-table New American fare with a luxurious setting.

Any insider tips for Family Meal at Blue Hill?

Make sure to check their seasonal menu for new items.

When should I visit Family Meal at Blue Hill?

Perfect for a celebratory dinner or business lunch.

Who should go to Family Meal at Blue Hill?

Food connoisseurs and special occasion diners.

Any insider tips for Marian's?

Reserve early for brunch to avoid long waits.

Who should go to Marian's?

Couples and brunch enthusiasts.

Any insider tips for The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea?

Get the daily oyster special for an extra treat!

When should I visit The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea?

Evenings for a romantic dinner.

Who should go to The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea?

Seafood lovers and date night seekers.

Any insider tips for Willow Vegan Bistro?

Their vegan burger is a local favorite!

When should I visit Willow Vegan Bistro?

For a healthy lunch or weekend brunch.

Who should go to Willow Vegan Bistro?

Vegan food lovers and health-conscious eaters.

Any insider tips for Brine?

Their pickled fries are a must-try side dish.

When should I visit Brine?

Casual weeknight or weekend outing.

Who should go to Brine?

Fans of casual comfort food and fried chicken.

Best American Restaurants in Chelsea (10011)

Q: What should I order at Family Meal at Blue Hill?

Farmhouse chicken, seasonal vegetables, baked apple tart.

Q: What should I order at Marian's?

Roasted chicken, grilled salmon, beef short ribs.

5 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: January 2026

🔖 Save List

Our Top Pick

Family Meal at Blue Hill

Refined farm-to-table New American fare with a luxurious setting.

Essential Picks

#1 Family Meal at Blue Hill

9.0

$$$$ Greenwich Village

Vibes: Luxury Dining Elite Date Night Magic Business Lunch Power Players

An upscale dining experience that focuses on farm-to-table New American cuisine.

Must-Try Dishes: Farmhouse Chicken, Seasonal Vegetables, Baked Apple Tart

What makes it special: Refined farm-to-table New American fare with a luxurious setting.

View Full Review →

Notable Picks

#2 Marian's

8.8

$ West Village

Vibes: Date Night Magic Brunch Bliss Spots Trendy Table Hotspots

A warm and welcoming spot offering delicious New American fare, with a menu that changes seasonally.

Must-Try Dishes: Roasted Chicken, Grilled Salmon, Beef Short Ribs

What makes it special: Seasonal New American menu with a cozy vibe.

View Full Review →

#3 The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea

8.5

$$$ Chelsea

Vibes: Date Night Magic Comfort Food Classics Rooftop Views Revelry

An upscale seafood joint offering fresh oysters, lobster rolls, and a cozy bar.

Must-Try Dishes: Lobster Roll, Oysters, Clam Chowder

What makes it special: Fresh seafood with a cozy, upscale ambiance.

View Full Review →

#4 Willow Vegan Bistro

8.4

$$$ Chelsea

Vibes: Healthy Haven Brunch Bliss Spots Comfort Food Classics

A vegan bistro offering fresh, plant-based dishes in a modern, inviting space.

Must-Try Dishes: Vegan Burger, Avocado Toast, Chickpea Salad

What makes it special: Vegan comfort food with a healthy twist.

View Full Review →

#5 Brine

8.3

$$ Chelsea

Vibes: Comfort Food Classics Quick Bites Champions Family Friendly Favorites

A casual eatery focusing on chicken, sandwiches, and modern American comfort food.

Must-Try Dishes: Fried Chicken Sandwich, Southern Fried Chicken, Pickled Fries

What makes it special: Fried chicken with modern twists and creative sides.

View Full Review →